Neighborhood Creep: Sexual Fantasies Do Come True

Neighborhood Creep tries to make two teen girl’s sexual fantasy come true. Part 2 of the Neighborhood Creep Series

Samantha waited for her friend Candice or Candy as she liked to be called by the entrance of the park. They normally hanged out at the park for a bit on Saturday, the sixteen year old African-American teen finally made her appearance, her black hair tied up in a ponytail, she carried a black handbag on her right shoulder, she wore a denim mini skirt and a white top which stopped above her navel, leaving her mid rift exposed. Her brown eyes lit up as she saw her friend Samantha by the entrance of the park.

“Hi Sam.”

“Hi Candy.”

The two girls gave each other a hug after after greeting one another. Samantha wore denim shorts and a yellow top, the sun glowed brightly against her white skin and her shoulder length brown hair was blowing against the wind, her blue eyes winced as another round of wind hit her in the face . The two friends entered the park and started gossiping about what happened when they were not at school together.

“So did you do anything exciting after school hours?” Asked Samantha

“Give me a minute.”

Candice’s eyes darted around to make sure no one else was there, she lifted up her skirt, removing her underwear she stuffed it into her handbag, this caused Samantha to raise a brow at her friends actions.

“What? I just wanted to get a bit more comfortable.” A mischievous smile graced Candice’s face. “Also to answer your question do you remember the neighborhood creep myself and the rest of the girls told you about?”

Samantha nodded, she kept a neutral expression as her mind re-called what happened last week Sunday when her parents were out of the house for a few hours.

“Well on Wednesday I caught him following me.” Said Candice “He followed me all the way to the house.”

“As soon as I got into the house, I went up to my bedroom and peaked out the window.” Candice paused smiling, she then continued. “I saw him hiding in a corner, I could see the sun shine off his bald head.” Candice giggled. “So I purposefully left the window blinds open and began to change out of my school uniform.”

Samantha listened with rapt attention as her friend carried on with her tale.

“I didn’t allow him to see much though.” Concluded Candice. “He only saw my bare brown butt.”

“That’s it?”

Candice turned to face Samantha, from the tone of her voice she sounded disappointed.

“Why were you expecting something more to happen?”

“Well…”

Samantha told Candice about her eventful Sunday night, needless to say Candice was shocked that her friend could even allow something like that to happen.

“You guys did it!” Candice exclaimed. “How big was he?”

“He’s more thick than big honestly it felt like he was stretching my pussy apart.”

Candice could feel her clit get a bit wet, she closed her eyes imagining herself there, getting pounded by the creeps cock with Sam’s pussy on top of her face as she ate it out.

“Earth to Candy!”

Candice opened her eyes, she felt her face flush, shaking her head she continued her walk with Sam.

“What were you thinking about?”

The two of them made it to the center of the park, there were a lot of families with their children running about.

Candice lowered her head staring at the ground. “I was thinking about us having a threesome with the creep.”

“I could still make it happen.”

“How?”

Samantha pulled out her cell-phone from her pocket, she checked her recent contacts and showed the creeps number to Candice.

“No way, you got his number.”

Samantha nodded. “My parents are going for a dinner tonight.” Samantha put her phone back into her pocket. “If you want I can invite you and him over?”

Candice contemplated about what Samantha asked. “Sure but let me confirm with my parents as well and I’ll send you a message.”

“Alright.”

The two teen girls took another route that lead to the park exit, unknown to them a bald headed man wearing black sunglasses and running attire had been following them ever since they entered the park from a distance, he grinned displaying his crooked teeth. Samantha made it back home, as she entered the house she saw her parents watching a movie on T.V.

“Mom, Dad can my friend Candice come over tonight?”

“Of course Dear.” Samantha’s Mom turned to face her Daughter. “I’ll make something for the two of you tonight and keep it in the fridge.”

“If anything happens while we are away don’t hesitate to call us.” Samantha’s Dad cautioned his only child.

“Will do Dad.”

Samantha ran up to her room to text Candice the good news.

Samantha: My parents said that you can come over

Candice: I asked my parents and they said yes 🙂

Samantha: Nice see you later

Samantha put her phone on her lap, the only thing she needed to do now was to inform the creep, she sent a message to his number.

Samantha: Hi it’s Samantha

Creep: Already got your number saved love I know its you

Samantha: Are you free to stop by the house today my parents are out?

Creep: I’m going to need some extra incentive to come over since I already fucked you last week

Samantha: I have a friend coming over

Creep: Which one?

Samantha: The one you were following on Wednesday she showed you her bare brown butt from her room window.

Creep: Ah I figured she was showing it to me on purpose can’t wait to see it up close

Samantha: My parents will be gone from 6:00 pm to 11:00 pm I’ll leave the back door for you unlocked

Creep: Thanks love see you later

Samantha put her cell-phone down, now all that was left to do was wait. By 5:40 pm she heard the doorbell ring answering it she saw her friend waiting outside, the two girls hugged each other. The two of them went to the living room where Samantha’s parents were all dressed up and ready to go out. Samantha’s parents greeted Candice informing her that there is some dinner in the fridge for later. The two of them headed out for the dinner bidding their daughter and her friend goodbye.

Samantha and Candice sat on the living room couch talking about what the creep did to Samantha last week.

Candice looked around the living room. “So this’s where you were fucked?”

“I was against it at first.” Samantha laughed “But later I just decided to enjoy it.”

The two girls started pitching ideas at what they wanted the creep to do to them. Meanwhile said creep had entered the backyard he checked the backdoor and found it was indeed unlocked. He headed inside careful to not make too much noise, he heard two girls voices coming from the living room and headed there, he saw the both of them on the couch talking, they still didn’t notice his presence. He crept up quietly towards them and put his right hand over Samantha’s mouth and his left hand over Candice’s mouth both girls let out muffled screams and began to struggle but stopped when the man let out a hearty chuckle.

“Got your girls good didn’t I?”

The man let go of both teen’s mouths, the two girls turned their head towards him glaring.

“Now don’t be like that.” The man said. “Why don’t the two of you get up so I can get a good look at you.”

Both girls got up from the couch, the man walked over to the couch and sat on it.

“Start stripping.” He ordered

Samantha began to take off her clothes but Candice stood their resolute.

“What’s stopping you…” The man paused. “What’s your name again?”

“It’s Candy.”

The man let out a snort. “What type of a parent would name their child that?”

“It’s short for Candice.”

“Well Candy I don’t have a lot of time to work with the both of you so start stripping.”

“That depends if you can answer my question.”

“Which is?”

“Am I wearing underwear right now or not?”

The man took a good look at Candice, she was wearing the same clothes that she was wearing at the park, a sly grin crept onto his face.

“You’re not.”

Candice blinked at the man’s answer. “How did you know?”

“I was following the two of you when you were at the park this morning.” Clarified the man. “Now that that’s out of the way remove the clothes.”

Candice removed her clothes, she was now naked alongside her friend Samantha both teens bearing their naked forms to this perverted man. The man licked his lips at the sight of the two teens.

“Nice, very nice.” The man complimented, he removed his shorts and underwear his thick cock sprang out at the two girls causing them to let out gasps. “My friend down here needs a bit more excitement.” The man pointed at his dick. “Why don’t you girls do a warm up then I’ll join in later.”

“A warm up as in?” Asked Samantha

“You know lesbian sex.” Stated the man. “Some girl on girl action.”

Samantha glanced at Candice, the African-American sixteen year old nodded, the two girls turned to face each other, they slowly walked towards one another, they stopped when they were a few inches from each other. Candice wrapped her arms around Samantha’s waist, her friend did the same. The two teens leaned forward, they each felt their nipples press against the others. Their lips met, for both of them it was their first time kissing a girl, the touch of their lips felt soft compared to a man’s lips, the girls make out session lasted 10 minutes before Candice broke the kiss. She then began kissing Samantha’s neck making her let out a soft moan, she went down to her nipples and started to suck on each of her pink areola’s, this caused Samantha to start breathing heavily while Candice continued downwards kissing Samantha’s stomach until she reached her vagina.

She stuck her tongue into her friends vagina, she could taste Samantha’s wet juices flowing out of her vagina onto her tongue. Candice continued licking her friends vagina for 15 minutes her tongue going in and out lapping up Samantha’s pre-cum. She stopped, getting up she kissed Samantha again, this was the second time Samantha had tasted her own come as her friends tongue was exploring her mouth. Samantha broke the kiss, she was panting hard.

“Lay down on the ground.” Candice whispered to Samantha

Samantha did just that, she was laying down on the ground her friend was soon on top of her with her pussy facing her.

“Lick my pussy.” Candice told Samantha

Samantha started licking her friends pussy while she did the same with hers. The two girls were at it for 20 minutes. The man was jacking off to the sight of the two teens having lesbian sex in front of him.

‘Ah chocolate and vanilla.’ The man thought. ‘My favorite.’

The man got up from the couch he felt now was the time to join in. “Alright girls my cock is nice and hard now for the both of you.”

The two girls didn’t hear him both lost in licking each others pussies.

“Girls!” The man yelled.

This got the girls attention as both of them looked up at him, cum dripping from their mouths. Both girls got off each other and crawled on all fours towards the creep. Samantha started licking the mans hairy balls while Candice sucked on the man’s thick cock.

‘His cock is stretching my mouth.’ Thought Candice.

Candice and Samantha sucked and licked the man’s cock and balls for 25 minutes, with each minute passed they felt their bodies get hotter and hotter, their cunts getting wetter and wetter. Candice felt drops of pre-cum from the creep’s dick land onto her tongue.

‘It tastes salty.’ She thought.

The man let out a satisfied grunt. “Alright girls you can stop.”

Both girls stopped, waiting for their the next order from the creep, the man pointed at Candice.

“I’ll need you on the couch.” He then pointed at Samantha. “Then I’ll need you to get on top of her.”

The two girls were in the position the man asked for their ass and pussy ready for whatever the creep had planned. The man thrusted his cock first into Candice’s pussy, she let out a yelp as she felt the creep’s cock enter. The man was surprised that she wasn’t a virgin.

“Are any of the girls at your school virgins?”

Samantha let out a light moan as the man started to finger her pussy while fucking her friends. “Maybe the nerds.”

The man continued to fuck and finger both teen girl’s, he kept pumping his dick into them switching from one to the other after every 10 minutes. Both girls should’ve been tired but the amount of dopamine the was going through their brains right now kept them very alert.

“So good.” Said Candice.

“So, good.” Repeated Samantha

The man was slowly reaching his climax, looking down at the two beautiful teens, he couldn’t help but smile at how lucky he got to fuck them.

“Shit I’m going to cum!” Yelled the man.

He took out his dick from Samantha’s pussy, she got off her friend. Both girls got down from the couch and were now kneeling on the ground eagerly awaiting the load of cum that was about to erupt from the creep’s cock, the two girls had their tongues stuck out. The man shot his load over the both of them, the two girls swallowed whatever cum landed on their tongues and licked the rest off each other, they shared a kiss afterwards spit swapping the creeps cum between them. The three of them sat naked on the couch Samantha switched on the T.V. and picked a random movie to watch. She checked the clock the time was 10:00 pm. They had been fucking for almost 4 hours straight. Samantha and Candice both leaned against the mans chest, the creep placed his left arm over Samantha and his right arm over Candice. 30 minutes later Samantha got up from the couch and got the dinner from the fridge and microwaved it, when she got back she found the creep giving some spanks to Candice’s ass cheeks he gave a cheeky grin to Samantha who smiled in return.

The three of them started to feed the dinner to each other, after it was finished the man got up from the couch stretching. Once he was done dressing, he turned to face the two girls who were still naked.

“Thanks for the wonderful weekend girls I really appreciate it.”

“Urgh my pussy is so loose.” Complained Candice.

“Give it a few days it will go back to normal then.” Samantha advised

The man let out a laugh. “Well if you girls need a good fuck you know who to call.”

“Can we get some kisses before you leave first?” Asked Samantha

“Why of course.”

The man leaned down and gave a sloppy wet kiss to both Samantha and Candice, he later left through the back door, waving goodbye to Samantha and her friend.

🔞 Candy.AI 🔥 AI Sex Chat - Roleplay, Erotic Stories, Try for Free 🕹️

Please, Rate This Story:

(average: 4.67 out of 12 votes)