Playing With Dicks – How boyhood experiments turn into teenage degeneracy – Chapter 15 (2)

Chapter 15 (Part 2) – Now that we know Clara is game to fool around, just how far will she let us go? Will this be the bisexual orgy we dreamed of?

WARNING: For patient readers only!

PLAYING WITH DICKS is a very long story tracing my entire early sexual history, and if you start reading here in the middle you’ll be missing a lot of important context. I recommend starting back from the very beginning so you’re not lost, or at least start at the recap in between chapters 10 & 11 so you know what’s going on. Click my username to find it all organized in order.

This is also an entirely true story, and I’ve included quite a bit of explanations and history to provide context between the “good parts” – so if you are expecting a barrage of wild unbelievable fantasy scenarios and non-stop sex scenes you may be a little disappointed. But if you are a patient reader and are willing to sit through my endless blabbing about my history, I promise those good parts will be worth it!

Playing With Dicks

How boyhood experiments turn into teenage degeneracy

Chapter 15 – The Clara Situation (Part 2)

Sitting there right next to Clara as she played with her pussy, I was so tempted to ask her if she’d let me try. I wanted to touch it so bad and try doing what she was doing, but I was too chickenshit to go for it, even as she kept staring over at my hard dick like she wanted to touch it. I don’t know if she was as nervous as me or just waiting for Grant’s permission or something, but all 5 of us just sat around playing with ourselves as Clara told us all about her secret little lesbian relationship with her best friend. It was amazing watching her rub and finger her tiny little pussy, but how she was so excited to watch us all stroking our dicks was the real exciting part.

I was still too close to the edge to really play with myself too much, so I just sat there beside Clara listening to her story and holding my hard dick, barely giving it two or three slow strokes every few seconds whenever she looked down at it. She said she wanted to masturbate first before she tried sucking some dick, and I hoped that meant she wanted to trade some hand jobs too because I was dying to feel her pussy. She kept staring at my erect cock as Grant interrogated her for more details about her friend, and after she had nothing else to say about it there was a bit of an awkward silence. Clara was getting good at breaking those though.

“So, umm, can I try? Can I touch it?” she asked me directly, looking straight at me playing with my dick. I don’t know if she picked me first because she liked me more or because I was conveniently close, but she did choose to sit down right beside me. I almost said no because I was still nervous dangerously close to the edge, but of course I couldn’t resist the thought of a cute little horny naked girl playing with my dick.

“Sure,” I replied quietly and nervously, “but only slowly,like this, ok?” I told her as I stroked my shaft and showed her.

“Like this?” she asked as she batted my hand out of the way and grabbed a loose hold of my dick, gently moving her hand up and down my shaft.

“Here, up a bit like this,” I said as I grabbed her hand and put it in the perfect spot on my shaft, and with my hand over hers I showed her exactly how tight to grab and how far to stroke up and down. Her hand was so tiny that when I let go my dick suddenly looked even bigger as she tried to grip it. She couldn’t even close her tiny fingers all the way around the girth of my shaft, but she knew how to stroke it and it felt amazing. Her hands were so soft and her grip perfectly tight, and those tiny little fingers felt so weird and good riding up and down my shaft. She carefully watched exactly what she was doing, and the whole time she kept playing with her pussy some more with her other hand.

I was still trying to muster up the courage to ask her if I could try touching her, or maybe just reach for it without asking, but she worked me right up to the edge too quickly. Not even 15 seconds after she grabbed my dick I had to stop her, I grabbed her hand and told her she was about to make me cum, and she looked at me with a big grin as she reluctantly let go of my dick. I was so horny I didn’t even hear her ask or offer me anything, but she just grabbed my free hand and dragged it down to her pussy.

This wasn’t how I ever thought my first time touching a vagina would be, with 3 of my closest male fuck buddies watching, but Clara guided my hand and fingers down into her crotch and I felt that beautiful soft wet pussy for the first time. Her skin was so soft and her pussy lips were so smooth, and it was so warm and wet when she pushed my fingers down between them. She showed me how to rub my fingers up and down her tight little slit, and I felt her hard little clit. She even told me to go in and pushed my hand until I curled my middle finger up inside her little hole. It was amazingly tight but so wonderfully slippery, it felt so nice but totally alien and weird.

But it was incredibly awkward because I’m right handed and she was trying to teach my fumbling left hand what to do, it was like trying to handwrite with my right hand tied behind my back. Well my right hand was actually still holding my throbbing hard cock, but I dare not even stroke it because I would have blown my load instantly. Even more awkward was how the guys were all looking at me and Clara, Grant had this facial expression I’d never seen a human make before as he stared at us – he looked horny but I didn’t know if he was proud of me or jealous I was getting some action first. But hey, Clara did say she was going to take turns after all, so I felt pretty special that she let me touch her first. And as fun as getting to finger her pussy was, I was so awkward trying to do it with my left hand that I was pretty much over it, it was just too weird.

I told Clara she should let someone else try, and she agreed. She gave me my hand back and I took it off her pussy, and my fingers were absolutely dripping in her juices. Part of me wanted to sniff and taste the strange clear fluid on my fingers, but I didn’t want to act like too much of a pervert so I casually wiped it off against my bare thigh. I got up to free up the spot on the sofa next to Clara and went to go sit in my bed on the floor to relax and reel myself back in from the edge.

While I lounged around for a moment I got to watch as Clara one by one went through all the guys and let them finger fuck her tight little pussy, teaching them all exactly how it’s done, trading little hand jobs with them along the way and stroking their dicks too. Grant obviously wasn’t actually jealous about it at all, he didn’t even try to hog Clara all to himself, he went last after letting Chris and Adam both have a try with her first. It was so crazy watching them do it, she was so eager and excited to teach all of us, and it looked like an opening scene to one of those gangbang pornos we’d seen. Chris was as awkward as I was touching her pussy but obviously loved it, even Adam eagerly joined in and got his little handful too and loved it. Grant had been there done that and didn’t need much instruction, but he played along like he still needed to learn too.

And Clara absolutely loved all the attention, she seemed totally overjoyed to be joining our secret club and loved the thought of being the one and only girl in on it. She was definitely getting some sick thrill out of letting all us touch her and the way we obsessed about her, and she was eager to learn how to give us all hand jobs and loved stroking all our dicks. Even if she was just as perverted and trustworthy as any one of the boys, she knew she’d still hold a super special power over us just for being a girl, even if we tried to treat her like an equal. She knew that by being our one and only chance at some easy pussy she could easily be the queen of our little club and have her way with us, we were all putty in her hands even though she was the young and inexperienced one.

She wielded that power right away and wasn’t afraid to stir things up, she was a lot more extroverted and enthusiastic about joining our little secret sex club than any other new male recruit before her. When she finally let Grant touch her pussy again, she started telling us to give each other blowjobs – if we expected her to join in and suck dick too then we really had to prove it and show her we weren’t scared to be gay around her. She was so desperate to watch us guys suck each other off that she even offered to let us eat her pussy out, but if we wanted to do that we had to earn it and keep things as fair as possible. She liked being the center of attention but she didn’t want to be the only one showing off, and she still hadn’t seen a whole lot of proof of how perverted we really are. Other than Grant giving me a ridiculously short blowjob it had pretty much been the Clara show since then, and we’d all just been kind of watching her teach us all how to finger fuck her.

Obviously some of us were doing something right because she got so horny she told Grant to stop rubbing her pussy, her legs were starting to tremble and she didn’t want to cum yet. She basically pushed him off her and closed her legs, and demanded to see some blowjobs if she was going to take it any further. I was getting pretty eager to show off again, so I gladly volunteered to suck Grant’s dick to get him back for earlier, and he agreed and waved me over. If Clara really wanted to watch, we were going to do it right in her face directly beside her.

I got down on my knees in front of Grant as he sat there on the sofa right next to Clara, and I bent over into his lap and started sucking his cock. I tried to look up sideways to see Clara’s reaction as I put Grant’s big dick in my mouth, but I couldn’t see her face from that angle, just her hand going back down between her legs as she started playing with herself again. I wanted to give her a good view and try to see her face, so I got all dramatic with it like Grant on me, stroking his cock with one hand and sliding it on my tongue as I bobbed my head up and down, switching between sucking him straight on and sideways.

With a little bit of Grant and Clara’s encouragement, Chris and Grant got in on the action too, and Adam started sucking Chris’s dick in the same position on the other sofa. I kind of wanted to watch to see how nervous the two of them still were, but I was too busy sucking Grant’s dick and trying to keep it going for a while this time. I wasn’t going to stop until he told me to, I’d never had more fun sucking a dick in my entire life with the way Clara was so excited to watch. I was used to showing off and being watched and even teaching a whole bunch of young first timers, I’d done exactly the same thing in front of most my friends, sometimes in groups of like 10 boys at a time – but the fact that it was a girl sitting right there watching and getting off to it, that was a whole different kind of thrill. And it went to the next level pretty quickly, I’d barely been sucking Grant’s dick for a minute or two when he finally told me to stop before I make him cum. I stopped and told I don’t care and I can keep going if he wants to cum in my mouth, but he said no, not yet. So I got off Grant and went to go find somewhere to sit, and Clara quietly chimed in again.

“So, umm, can I try now?” she asked hesitantly, eyes darting back and forth between me and Grant.

“Not on me,” Grant said to her, “not unless you want cum in your mouth.”

“Ew no,” she barked at Grant, but then looked at me and asked, “but… Can I try on you?”

“Umm, sure,” I replied, still shocked by her bold offer even though it was totally in character for her. I was surprised and flattered by how she kept wanting to try everything on me first, and I honestly wasn’t expecting a fantastic blowjob from her, I was just stoked to get my dick sucked by a girl for the first time ever. She looked eager and shuffled forward in her seat like she was going to get up and follow me, but I had a better idea and told her, “hold on, stay right there,”

The sofa was so low slung and she was so short that her face was already at perfect height if she kept sitting there and I just stood in front of her, so I side stepped my way past Grant into position and held my throbbing dick out right in front of Clara’s face.

“Don’t cum in my mouth tho, ok?” she reminded me.

“I won’t, but you gotta stop if I tell you to,” I warned her.

“Okay,” Clara said as she opened her mouth and leaned forward, grabbed my shaft with her tiny hand and guided my hard dick into her mouth.

Like her hands and every other part of her, that mouth was tiny too – she cranked her jaw wide open so my dick would fit, and there was no way she’d fit more than half the length in, but she tried anyway. Grant had obviously already taught her something, she knew how to keep her teeth out of the way, and as soon as she hit her limit and almost gagged on it, she started bobbing back and forth and licking my shaft. Her tiny little tongue felt amazing swirling up and down my dick, she even took a few breaks from trying to choke herself with it to gently lick the head all over, even tongue flicking my dick hole a little bit. She didn’t need any instruction or pointers, she was pretty skilled at sucking dick and wasn’t afraid to show off those skills. Either Grant had already taught her well in a short amount of time, or she was holding out on us and still had other secrets, because she knew how to give a pretty good blowjob. She wasn’t as good or as well practiced as most of the guys, but the fact that she was female and I was getting my first ever blowjob from a girl more than made up for it with all the added excitement.

I told her it feels good, but she needed to either slow down if she wanted to keep going, or stop before I went over the edge. She was about to make me cum even faster than Grant did earlier, so after warning her to slow down a bit I got really brave and put my hand on the back of her head. It felt kind of weird because it was a move we rarely did among the guys, only Adam and Jay and I actually liked being guided by the head like that, but I figured Clara might too and I had to slow her down. I ran my fingers through her short brown hair and slowed her head from bobbing so fast, and she went right along and let me move her head and set the pace.

Even after I slowed Clara way down, I still wasn’t going to last much longer, I was so excited about my first real blowjob from a girl I was pretty much on the edge of blowing my load the whole time. Looking down at her petite naked body and her cute little face struggling with my cock in her mouth, for some reason it felt almost dirtier than anything I’d done before. Probably because I’d imagined this moment as some romantic bullshit special night with an actual girlfriend, not just at another orgy in The Dungeon except with a slutty girl this time. Whatever, it was way more fun this way.

After a pretty short little blowjob I had to stop Clara, I couldn’t take it anymore and had to pull away before I blew my load on her tongue. She didn’t look like she wanted to stop, but she did warn me not to cum in her mouth – so I did the polite thing and told her to stop, and she looked quite proud of herself for getting me right to the edge of orgasm that fast. I stepped back and went to go sit on the floor somewhere again, and I relaxed and tried to work my way back from the edge yet again.

This time as I lounged around I got to watch Clara take a tour of the whole room and give everyone blowjobs one by one, sucking everyone’s dicks right up to the edge. Watching her take turns sucking my friends’ dicks right in front of me was so exciting it was totally worth sharing her around. I mean who needs a girlfriend when you can have a secret little slut friend like her? Grant was so close to blowing his load as well that he barely let Clara touch him, she spent way more time sucking off Chris and Adam, giving them each good long blowjobs right until they were both about to explode too. Adam was still young enough he couldn’t shoot cum into Clara’s mouth if he wanted to, but even he stopped her from pushing him over the edge. As usual we were all trying to stretch it out and extend the fun as much as we could so nobody wanted to cum quite yet, Clara included. It was still only just barely past bedtime anyway – all this was going on and it wasn’t even close to midnight yet.

The obvious question came back up as Clara was busy sucking all our cocks – was she still going to teach us all how to eat her pussy? I know I was dying to try it out, and so was Chris because he was the one who brought it back up. Clara was excited for us to return the favor and eat her out, and since he had the guts to say something and offer himself up to her, of course Chris got to have the first try. He said he didn’t really know what to do, but Clara said it’s okay because she was going to teach him everything. I couldn’t wait to learn how to eat pussy, but I was so nervous about it I was relieved she didn’t pick me first this time.

She told him it was easier lying down, and she borrowed Chris’s bed in the middle of the floor, got down on her back and spread her legs wide apart. Chris eagerly dove right in and started licking up and down between her pussy lips, and it was so crazy to watch. She did her best to explain how to do it, where and how to lick, telling him to do it harder, and I just watched and tried to learn. I’d seen it enough times in porn that I thought I knew what to do, but obviously posing for pictures or acting for movies is a lot different than actually diving in and making it feel good. He was basically making out with her pussy, face all squished up between her legs, nodding his head up and down as he licked her hard and deep.

Clara was obviously enjoying it. As Chris quickly figured out what to do, she laid her head back and let out a quiet little “mmMMMmmm”, not quite a moan but just a soft hum of pleasure. She started squirming a little bit and let him keep going for a little while, but she didn’t let him get too carried away and eventually told him to stop, breathing heavy all of a sudden. Chris came up for air and pulled his face up out of her pussy, and Clara closed her legs and rolled onto her side, still squirming and gently humming to herself.

“Holy shit, did I make you cum?” Chris asked her bluntly as he wiped her pussy juice off his face and gave her some space.

“Mmmm no, but almost,” she whispered, laying there with her hand back over her pussy, “mmm that feels good!”

“Sure looks like it does, holy shit Clara!” Grant said to her softly, and in a much gentler tone than before he asked, “do you need a break, or can I try too?”

“You can try if you want,” she replied, rolling onto her back again and spreading her legs wide open.

So Grant and Chris traded places, and Clara spread her legs for him and Grant got right to work. She started her little “mmmm” humming almost immediately, Grant had been listening to all the instructions she gave Chris and picked up on it quickly himself, easily making her squirm and blush like never before. I could barely see but it almost looked like her pussy was all swollen and engorged, pussy lips all puffy as Grant drove his tongue between them and made her go nuts.

After only a minute of letting Grant eat her out, Clara started squirming and humming again and her legs were trembling, she looked like she was mid-orgasm but she stopped Grant anyway, before he got too carried away. When he came up for air I looked down at her pussy and it really was all puffy and her lips looked swollen, all dripping wet too, she definitely had whatever the female equivalent of a throbbing hard erection going on down there. She quickly covered it up with her hand again, grabbing her pussy and closing her legs she kept squirming for a few seconds, enjoying the lingering sensation.

Me and Adam looked at each other like “ok, who’s next?” expecting to take turns eating her out next. None of us really knew anything about how different the female orgasm is from what we were used to. I didn’t know if she just came or not, or if she even wanted to yet, maybe she was holding off like we were. The way she clasped her pussy and laid there humming and squirming looked like she either just came, or she was trying to stop herself from going over the edge. I wished I could feel whatever she was feeling because it looked amazing, and I just wanted to know what was going on and give her the same pleasurable feelings.

Either way, she did finally need a bit of a break, and in a soft voice Clara told us she needed to stop for a minute because she was getting really sensitive. We totally understood, we could all relate to that, so we let her lay there on Chris’s bed and started talking about what else we could do. Grant asked Clara if she wanted to try 69 too because it’s even more fun that way, and she said she still needed a break but totally would, and totally wanted to see us do it first. So Grant and Chris paired up and got down on the floor right beside Clara, Chris laid out on his back and Grant crawled over on top of him facing the other way. They both started sucking each other’s dicks simultaneously while Clara leaned in for a good close look, laying on her side watching them, hand still on her pussy and totally getting off watching the live gay sex show. She really was loving every second of it, she was having exactly as much fun watching us do gay stuff together as us guys would have watching lesbians do their thing, which she proved when she broke the silence again with her next most awkward question.

“So, is sucking each other off the only thing you guys do?” she asked shyly, “or have you guys ever tried other stuff too?”

“Why? Like what?” Grant spat Chris’s dick out and asked her, shocked by what she was asking and implying.

“I dunno, you guys are the experts,” Clara said half sarcastically, “what do I know?”

“Don’t act dumb, we all know what you mean,” Grant atold her bluntly as he started crawling back off of Chris, “you can just ask, y’know? I’m not scared of telling you, as long as you don’t get grossed out.”

“Wait, so you have tried something else? Like, something dirtier? Like what?” Clara asked.

“You really wanna know?” Grant asked her all seriously.

“Yeah totally! I think I deserve to know by now,” she said all entitled like she was one of us, “I don’t care if this makes me weird or whatever, but I think it’s cool how you guys are so chill about gay stuff, like, you guys are way cooler than all my guy friends back home!”

“Wow, you really are a pervert, you know that?” Grant shot back at her, “Why are you so obsessed with gay sex? What else do you think we tried?”

“I don’t know, I just think it’s cool, that’s why I was asking,” she replied, “you can tell me, I promise I won’t tell anyone or make fun of you guys!”

“Just say it Clara, don’t be a pussy,” Grant said to her, “c’mon, what else do you think is so bad we wouldn’t tell you about?”

“OK fine, but promise you won’t get mad or think I’m weird.”

“You are weird, but won’t get mad, right guys?” Grant said as we all nodded along, dying to hear whatever Clara was about to say.

“Fine then, sorry if this sounds stupid,” she started out pre-qualifying her question, “but have you guys tried anal?” she asked so blatantly it was a shock to hear the words come out of her mouth.

“Umm,” Grant replied after a bit of a surprised pause, not knowing exactly how to answer, scanning the rest of our reactions and seeing us just as bewildered. “That wouldn’t gross you out?” he asked her.

“I dunno, I’m just curious I guess. Aren’t you guys curious? I thought maybe you guys tried it, sorry if that’s weird or gross or whatever,” Clara said to us all in a way only she could make such a topic sound so casual.

“Why are you so curious, do YOU want to try anal? Like instead of normal sex?” Grant asked her plainly, still being the only one of us with the balls to talk to her like that.

“No, I didn’t say that,” Clara replied, probably lying judging by her inquisitive rambling, “but don’t you guys ever get tempted? You’re not curious how it feels? Even like you said, like, just instead of actual sex – you guys seriously never tried it?”

“I never said that we didn’t,” Grant replied, finally letting the truth sneak out into the open.

“No way! Really? So you have tried it?” Clara asked, in utter shock from Grant’s confession.

“Yean, we tried anal, like, a lot,” he replied straightforwardly, looking over at us guys, “all of us have done it, even Matt and Jay too, right guys? So what?”

“That’s crazy – so you guys all, like, actually tried, y’know, like, sticking it inside, for real?” she asked while hilariously making the finger-in-hole hand gesture.

“Yeah, so? You don’t think it’s gross?” he asked.

“No, not really I guess, but that’s crazy,” she replied getting even more intrigued.

“We didn’t want to tell you because we thought it would gross you out,” Grant admitted, “but it’s actually pretty awesome, do you want to try?” he asked bluntly.

“I didn’t say that,” Clara clarified, “but that’s so cool you guys actually tried it, like how does it actually feel?”

“Well obviously it can feel really good,” he told her, “we wouldn’t do it if it didn’t feel good. But it’s not easy, you gotta be ready and know how to do it – you wanna try it? We can show you how…”

“I dunno, I don’t think I want to,” she replied all quiet and hesitant for once, “but can I please please watch you guys do it? Like, what does it actually feel like? Does it hurt? Because I’m not gonna try unless you guys show me first, so, like, can I just see you guys do it?”

“Sure I guess,” Grant replied to her, “I was holding back because I thought that anal would gross you out!”

“No way, I wanna see that, please can I watch?” she begged.

“Well if you think it’s cool I don’t care if you wanna watch, do you guys care? Should we show her?” he asked me and Chris and Adam.

“That would be so cool,” Clara said, “oh my God please can I watch? Please? I don’t care if that makes me a pervert, I wanna see!” she begged.

Her total judgment free open mindedness was such a turn on for me I couldn’t resist, and I was finally starting to follow Grant’s lead and be a lot more brave around her. I still wanted to ask if I’d get a turn eating her pussy too, but I figured why not really earn it and let her watch me get fucked first? She seemed so eager to see, and I couldn’t believe she was actually considering trying it herself! So even though Adam was probably more of a bottom than me, I wasn’t nearly as shy and thought I was the best candidate to show Clara how fun taking in the ass can be.

“I’m not shy about it,” I finally butted in, “I’ll help show you if you want,” I said to Clara. “You want me to?” I asked Grant, already shuffling myself into position on all fours like an eager puppy and sticking my ass out.

“Yeah let’s do it,” Grant said, all eager to show off himself. Chris was still right there next to him and instinctively gave him a quick little blowjob to lube Grant’s big dick up, and I got into receiving position right next to Clara where she could see the action clearly from nice and up close.

Grant waddled over on his knees and got into classic doggystyle position behind me, and Clara sat up right beside him to watch as he lined his dick up with my hole. I looked back over my shoulder at them as they both stared down at my ass with intense concentration, and when I felt the wet head of Grant’s cock touch my hole I relaxed, and he wasted no time pushing that meaty big shaft into me. I felt him sliding in slow and deep and filling me up as I turned my head around backwards to watch Clara’s reaction, and she was quietly amazed.

“Woah, holy shit,” she whispered as she stared down, “it’s actually going inside him, that’s crazy…”

“Yeah, duh, that’s what anal is, dumbass, look,” Grant said patronizingly to her as he pulled his dick most of the way out and pushed back in just to show her we weren’t faking anything and the penetration was real.

“No, I know that,” she said back, watching closely, “but it just looks so weird going in there, does it feel weird?”

“It feels awesome, probably as good as real sex,” Grant unashamedly said as he started slowly pumping his cock in and out of me.

“No I mean for you,” Clara asked me looking in my eyes, “does it hurt?”

“No, not at all,” I replied honestly, smiling back at both of them as Grant started speeding up and fucking me harder and deeper.

“Really? It doesn’t bother you or feel weird?” she asked again, “Like, how does it actually feel going inside you like that?”

“I dunno,” I said as Grant’s thrusts kept getting harder, “I don’t even care if this makes me gay, but I actually kind of like it, feels kind of weird but really good,” I went on as I had to straighten my head out and brace myself. Grant was starting to pump so hard and fast I had to get comfortable, and Clara just kept watching totally amazed by it all.

“So, what, like, it actually feels good for you too?” Clara asked me quietly and suspiciously.

“I don’t know how to explain it, but yeah, it’s weird,” I replied between thrusts, “but yeah, I like it, it feels good.”

Clara couldn’t quite wrap her head around it and kept nervously interrogating all of us about it as Grant kept pounding my ass right in front of her. She wanted to know who all tried it and if they thought it felt good too, she wanted to know how we even started doing anal in the first place and how we even learned to do it. Of course she had all the usual questions and concerns about cleanliness any anal virgin would, so we told her what we’d learned about preparation and pre-cleaning. Since we seemed to be such experts she wondered how we even knew so much about it, if we’d figured it out on our own or where we learned all this stuff. She was totally fascinated with it and didn’t make fun of us or call us fags, she was just amused and amazed by it all and thought it was cool that we were brave enough to take it that far, so we gladly told her everything and filled her in on the details.

We told Clara all about everything Chris had found online and all the porn we’d been downloading, how that not only inspired us to try anal but also taught us how, and that opened up a whole other new exciting thing to explore. Clara wanted to see our porn collection, so Chris fired up the computer to show her, and with her attention diverted elsewhere Grant decided to stop fucking me and we all gathered around the monitor to show Clara all the wild stuff we’d downloaded.

Not a whole lot happened for the next little while as Chris let Clara sit at the computer desk and browse through the ever growing collection of porn he had saved, and she got a kick out of it all. She had never seen any porn before so it totally blew her mind, she loved all the hardcore gay porn and the straight stuff too, even though almost all we had saved was pretty hardcore and dirty. She even loved the wild gangbangs and group sex stuff, even the messy cumshots and rimjobs. The only thing we surprisingly didn’t have much to show her was lesbian porn, we had a little bit, but for some reason that was one of the smaller folders.

The conversation got a whole lot more open and dirty too now that we well and truly didn’t have anything left to hide from Clara. She really was just as much of a total degenerate as any one of us, and truly did fit right in like just another new member of the secret club. We told her the whole extent of everything, how we had big circle jerks and traded blowjobs with so many friends and random boys in the neighbourhood. She was shocked to find out that the secret gay sex club was far from just us, and basically there was a huge unspoken gay thing going on for years among almost all the boys we knew. It was big enough that we just kind of assumed it was commonplace and we really did assume most guys played with dicks together to some degree – we were just the few open minded perverts who took it all the way, an elite VIP group if you want to put it that way. It was almost unbelievable to her that so many guys would be into having some secret gay fun on the side, but the thought of it really turned her on, especially when we told her we could prove it to her if she wants. We told her about the fort in the ravine and the cruising spot out behind the RV parking lot, inviting her to show up at one of those sessions one day, if she had the guys. We even told her all about the dangerous fun we used to have at the pool before we got busted in the change room – and we told her all about that incident, how the groundskeeper at my apartments was the only adult who probably knew what was going on but had thankfully kept our secret and didn’t even rat us out.

Clara told us she got busted once too, her best friend’s mom caught them humping each other at a sleepover years ago when they were only 7 or 8, but all they got was a gentle lecture and didn’t even get in any real trouble for it. Clara’s mom found out but didn’t even do anything about it or punish her, she even let the girls keep having sleepovers and let them continue sleeping in the same room even after she knew what they did in private. Her mom obviously didn’t care, she was the one who also let Grant sleep in Clara’s room even after that incident. Clara said her mom really was clueless and didn’t give a fuck what she did, which was clearly obvious now that she’d let her daughter spend the night in a basement full of horny adolescent boys – and look what ended up happening!

I guess the thought of any of their precious innocent little kids being sexually active was just too far fetched to even be a concern for any of our clueless parents, and I guess it’s understandable because of how young and generally well behaved we were – none of us were even teenagers yet and we weren’t known for getting into trouble. You’d think maybe Chris’s dad would have been enough of a man of the house to intervene on the moms’ lax permissive attitudes and not let Clara have her way and sleep downstairs with us, but he was also such a clueless ineffectual nothing that I don’t think he even realized Clara was spending the night down there with us.

It didn’t take long to get bored of looking at porn when we could be live performing it for each other, and things quickly got even wilder after that. All the nervousness about doing stuff in front of Clara disappeared and we started showing her a lot more, but we were all still a little nervous about her showing us stuff and teaching us about the one thing we still knew nothing about – pussy. We got back on the whole oral sex and 69 topic pretty quick, and me and Adam were both dying to try eating Clara out at that point, and she was more than happy to teach us how.

I wanted to see if I could eat her pussy good enough to make Clara cum, so I graciously let Adam try first so he could warm her up for me, and so I could get a little refresher course listening in as she taught him. They did it right out in the middle of the floor so we could all watch, and Clara got on her back and spread her legs for him. Adam stuck his face right in there and went for it, doing exactly what Clara told him as she coached him through it. I never thought I’d see little effeminate Adam acting so heterosexually, and it wasn’t some act either, he seemed to love eating pussy as much as any of us. He made out with her pussy and tongued her clit long enough to get the hang of it, and Clara soon started humming that adorable little “mmMMmmm” again.

Before they got too carried away with it, after a solid couple minutes of eating her out Adam had to catch his breath and said he needed a break. I was right there next to him watching, so I basically tagged myself in and told Adam to get out of my way, it was my turn now. I shuffled into position between Clara’s legs and looked down at her puffy wet little pussy. I didn’t care that I was last in line after my buddies or how much of a dirty slut she was, all I wanted to do was make her feel good and maybe make her cum. For the privilege of letting us fool around with her that night she definitely deserved an orgasm, and I was going to try and give it to her.

So I lowered my head into her crotch, stuck out my tongue and licked her pussy lips, first gently on the outside, then pushing my tongue between the lips into her tight slit. It felt and tasted so weird, she was all wet and slimy and kind of sticky sweet, her pussy had this slightly musky flavor like nothing else I’d ever tasted. The flavor definitely wasn’t bad, and the shape and texture of her pussy was so cool and interesting. Her outer labia just felt and tasted like normal skin, but the inner labia and all everything between was a whole different kind of smooth pink flesh, and the harder I licked it the more Clara seemed to like it.

“Mmmm yeah” she started humming quietly again, especially when I felt that little hard clit against my tongue and started playing with it. I even tried tongue fucking her hole a bit too, but that didn’t seem to do much for her even though it felt super weird and fun for me. Her pussy just kept getting wetter too, and not because I was slobbering all over it, her juices were flowing like crazy and my chin was dripping. She didn’t even really tell me what to do too much, I more or less figured it out from watching everyone else, and with nobody else waiting their turn I just kept going and going. I wasn’t going to stop unless I ran out of breath or she stopped me.

Pretty soon Clara’s little hums of pleasure started turning into the cutest little grunts and paused breaths like she was exerting herself, and she started squirming a little bit. I just went at it harder, rubbing her clit with my tongue, letting her set the pace as she started gyrating her hips and moving her pussy against my mouth.

“Oh my God, you’re gonna make me cum,” she carefully whispered as she fought back some actual moans.

“Is that ok?” I stopped long enough to ask her.

“Yeah! Don’t stop!” she told me as she grabbed the back of my head and jammed my face back down into her pussy. “Mmmm yeah,” she started quietly moaning as I started making out with her pussy again. I focused on her clit since that’s what she really seemed to like, and I just stuck my tongue out wide and flat and rubbed that clit up and down as hard as I dare. Her legs started to quiver and she could barely lay still, and she started quietly repeating “oh my God,” over and over again through short little labored breaths. She grabbed a handful of my hair at the back of my head and jammed my face hard into her, basically holding my head as she humped my mouth. This was it, I was actually making her cum, and cum hard.

It seemed to go on forever, I didn’t understand how the peak of an orgasm could last so long, and of course there isn’t the same kind of obvious release and relief I was used to because female orgasms are just somehow different. So I held in there and kept at it even though I was getting out of breath, just licking that clit harder and faster until she finally told me to slow down. It was so weird how she didn’t just crash over the edge after all that build up, the way she came was like she gently ramped up to the climax and then just stayed there, only slowly tapering back off, not exactly how we’d seen depicted in porn videos. It was interesting how the amateur written erotica stories we read did a better job of describing female orgasms that any videos we’d seen, and finally getting to see one happen in real life was amazing. Double amazing because I was the one who did it to her, she actually let me make her cum. She eventually felt finished enough to tell me to stop, so I came up for air and looked up at her face to see her reaction.

“Wow, did I make you cum?” I asked her.

“Oh my God yeah,” she replied quietly, still catching her breath, “that felt so good!”

“Yeah that was fun,” I said as I gave her some space, and again she tucked her hand into her crotch and closed her legs, trembling a bit as she lay there savoring the sensation. Another thing we learned about the female orgasm was her complete lack of any shred of post nut clarity, or whatever the female equivalent would be. If anything having an orgasm only seemed to make her even more horny, she had absolutely no shame or refractory period, no need to take time to recover, and she wanted to see some more action and keep things going immediately.

None of us not even Grant dared to question Clara’s rule of “no actual sex” she laid out before this all got started, but we didn’t really care because she really enjoyed sucking dick. She started getting a lot more dirty with it as we started getting into some more complicated group positions, crawling under Grant to suck his dick while I was busy fucking him. She 69ed with Adam while Chris was fucking him, and she was still so curious about anal sex that we almost talked her into trying it herself. If she didn’t want to lose her virginity and wasn’t going to let any of us fuck her in the pussy, letting us fuck her ass would probably be just as good, we could even cum inside her that way without worrying about knocking her up.

And while she held true to not letting any of us actually fuck her for real, she was still a little too hesitant to let to try anal instead as a replacement, even as we kept bugging her and encouraging her to try it. She was definitely getting more curious about it and loved watching us fuck each other, but she just wasn’t quite prepared to try taking a dick in her ass.

But among the guys we had yet another way to simulate sex that sometimes felt even closer to the real thing, and when we showed her how we like to rub and grind our dicks together and dry hump each other face to face, she got a pretty wild idea how she could join in on that too. She definitely wanted to hump and at least pretend to fuck, so she wanted to try just grinding her pussy against one of our dicks without actually sticking it in, just dick riding and rubbing it between her lips and on her clit – as long as there was no penetration it wouldn’t actually count, right? It’s not fucking if it’s just humping, or so the theory went, and we were all dying to see what she meant.

I don’t know how I got to be the lucky one she wanted to try it with, but she told me to lay on my back so she could get on top and show us all exactly what she meant. So I laid out in my bed with my hard cock sticking straight up, and Clara crawled on top of me and kneeled over me with her legs spread on both sides of my body, tantalizing me with her pussy hovering right above my cock. She started lowering her pussy down towards my dick, and she grabbed my shaft with one hand to push it up flat against my belly as she slowly lowered herself onto it. She carefully pressed her wet pussy low down onto the underside of my dick, down the shaft close to my balls, and I felt her lips spread around my dick on both sides. Keeping her torso upright she let a bit of her weight down onto my dick and started sliding it vertically up and down her slit between her pussy lips, not even close to sticking it in, just using my hard cock as something to rub her clit against. With her on top and in control, she kept her tight little hole far enough down away from my tip that I couldn’t even stick it in accidentally.

It felt so amazingly good I didn’t care she wasn’t going to let me stick it in, and as I looked down the visual of my cock mushed up between her pussy lips was the coolest thing I’d ever seen. The guys all gathered around to look too and saw what she meant by humping but not actually fucking, and they were all a bit jealous and wanted to try it too. But Clara wanted to keep riding me for a minute and actually let herself fall forward down onto my chest, pressing our naked bodies together and rhythmically humping me as if we were really fucking. She put her head down on my shoulder as we pressed some naked skin together, I could barely feel the two little lumps of developing beasts she had but it felt amazing having her chest touching mine. She put one arm behind my neck and hugged me hard as she kept humping me and sliding her pussy around on my shaft, so I hugged her back and ran my hands up and down her back, feeling out her body. I even grabbed her ass, one cheek in each hand and pushed and grinded her even harder, and that just set her off more and more.

“Mmm…” she started again with the sexy humming, this time breathing right in my ear softly. It felt so amazing that even without actually penetrating her it still felt almost like we were actually having full on sex, and it was just as good as I imagined it. I kept thinking how silly Clara was for going this far with us but still pretending there was some level of purity she had to maintain and stay a virgin, and I didn’t know why she made such a big deal about not actually sticking it inside her. I was starting to really lose myself in the moment and I was getting brave, so with my hands firmly grasping her ass cheeks I tried making her ride me a bit higher and higher up my shaft, trying to force her hole closer to my tip as she kept gyrating her hips and grinding on me. She’d let so much slide so far that maybe she’d lose herself in the moment too and let me do it, or maybe I could just overpower her and shove it in and pretend it’s an accident.

Unfortunately she picked up on what I was trying to do and started fighting me before getting too close. I’d try lifting her hips by her ass up into penetration position, but she’d just firmly brace herself with her hands on the floor and strongly push herself back down out of the danger zone. She didn’t say anything or call me out on it though, she just softly giggled in my ear and kept fighting and teasing me as she rode my dick up and down. All I wanted was to dip my tip in a bit to see if she’d go for it, but she fought me all the way with surprising strength, keeping her pussy hole riding my shaft way too low to stick it in, just grinding against me and pulverizing the head of my cock between our pubic bones.

It felt so good and the little physical battle we were having was so exciting that I didn’t last more than a minute or two before I felt the point of no return quickly approaching. She was pretty strong but I could have easily overpowered her and simply lifted her up onto my dick to shove it in, but I gave up on that idea as I felt a wickedly strong orgasm start building up.

“Slow down,” I whispered to Clara, warning her, “or you’re gonna make me cum.”

“That’s ok,” she replied softly, “you made me cum, why can’t I make you cum?”

“Mmmm not yet,” I told her, “I don’t want to make a mess.”

“Aww, that’s too bad,” she said as she slowed down and slowly started peeling her body up off of mine, but keeping her pussy pressed against my dick and still slowly grinding now in more of a cowgirl position. “Are you sure?” She asked, still slowly rotating her hips, “I wanna make you cum, I wanna see it!”

“Oh my God stop! Not yet!” I begged her as she had me pinned and wouldn’t stop moving. I was mere seconds from blowing my load, it was almost too late, I felt the tingle in my balls and the tension in my body building up. I had to ask her again, “please stop, or I’m gonna cum!” as I started squirming underneath her and trying to hold her hips to stop her from humping me anymore.

“Ok fine,” she said, sounding disappointed as she finally stopped and lifted herself off me, and then she asked, “but I don’t get it, why don’t you wanna cum?” looking kind of rejected. If she had gone for one more second I would have exploded, she stopped just in the knick of time, and my brain was too scrambled to explain the intricacies of refractory periods and post nut clarity to her.

“I told you, I don’t want to make a mess,” I said to her, “you would have been covered in it too!”

“So?” she asked plainly, “I don’t care, I still haven’t seen any of you guys cum yet, I wanna see!”

“Yeah but I didn’t think you wanted cum all over you,” I said, “and I don’t really want to cum yet, I’m having too much fun, that felt really really good!”

“That DID feel good,” Clara said shyly, “but why do you guys keep stopping like that? Why don’t you want to cum in front of me? I’m not gonna get grossed out, I promise!”

“I’ll show you if you want,” I said, getting kind of ballsy again, “do you still want to make me cum? I can cum in your mouth if you want to taste it,” I boldly suggested to her, kind of teasing her because I knew she thought it was icky.

“Ew, no,” she replied, “that’s not what I meant, I don’t know what about that…”

“Didn’t you just say you weren’t gonna get grossed out?” I challenged her, “It’s really not that bad, I wouldn’t swallow so much if I didn’t like the taste.”

“I dunno,” she wavered, “if you actually like then prove it and show me first, I’ll try tasting some cum if you do it first.”

“I’ll do it,” Grant perked up and asked Clara, “if I swallow his cum are you gonna swallow mine?”

“I never said I would swallow!” Clara replied, “I’m just curious how it tastes, I’m not gonna swallow it if it’s gross.”

“It’s not gross,” I interrupted her before Grant could say anything with an idea of my own, “I swallow my own cum all the time, you wanna see?” I asked referring back to my self sucking skills.

“I wanna see him do it!” Clara said pointing at Grant, “He just said he would, I wanna see that.”

“Okay,” Grant and I replied simultaneously, and I got up and walked over to him.

“Tell me when, ok?” Grant said as he kneeled down in front of me and started sucking my dick. My whole shaft was still soaked in Clara’s clear slimy pussy juices and he slurped and sucked it all clean off, and wasted no time trying to make me cum as quickly as possible. He bobbed his head back and forth and rammed my cock down into gag reflex territory but didn’t choke, going hands free and trying to finish me off using nothing but his mouth. Clara quickly crawled her naked little body over right next to us where she could see better, and she stared intensely at Grant blowing me from almost uncomfortably close up, standing there rubbing her pussy with one hand as she watched.

Clara had me so worked up it took only 15 or 20 seconds until Grant pushed me over the edge, and I gave him ample warning and told him I was about to cum. As I was going past the point of no return I grabbed my shaft with one hand right as Grant took my cock out of his mouth and opened up wide, sticking his tongue out to catch my load. I aimed carefully as I felt the twitching start, and one of the wildest orgasms I’d ever had started washing over me. My toes curled and my legs tensed up so hard I almost lost balance, I couldn’t even breathe as long and forceful squirts of cum started shooting out of my dick. I held the head of my cock down on the tip of Grant’s tongue, and pulse after pulse I started draining my balls right into his mouth. Not a drop spilled and no messy facial this time, he stayed still and let it pool on his tongue and make a pretty good visual spectacle of it so Clara could really see.

“Woah,” was all Clara quietly said as she watched me blow my load into Grant’s mouth. She seemed pretty impressed that Grant wasn’t gagging or wincing as I filled his mouth with gooey white slime, and when I was finished he milked the last drops out of my shaft and kept playing with it for a moment to really prove his point. The post nut clarity hit me so hard and fast I had to just back away slowly, and Grant dramatically closed his mouth and swallowed my load in one big gulp.

“See? It’s not bad,” Grant said to Clara, opening his mouth to prove it was all gone.

“You guys are crazy,” she said, “I can’t believe you just did that! It doesn’t gross you out?”

“Mmm no, like the taste,” Grant said as he cleared his mouth and swallowed the last remaining bits, “you said it wouldn’t gross you out either, you should just try it, you said you would! It doesn’t taste bad…”

“What does it actually taste like though? What if it makes me gag?”

“You won’t, and how do you know unless you try? You’re gonna like it, it’s kinda sweet and creamy.”

“But what if I don’t like it? What if I want to spit it out?”

I had to sit through this little argument as I was coming down of a mind shattering orgasm, crawling back to my bed on the floor and listening to Grant as he tried to convince Clara to let him blow his load in her mouth. We’d finally found her limit and she was super reluctant despite being so curious about it and getting all horny watching Grant swallow my cum. It was wild how much of a pervert she was turning out to be, but we still managed to push her right to her limits – she definitely wasn’t going to try anal, and she still didn’t want any of us to cum in her mouth. But Grant tried one last time to hold her to her word, saying she pretty much promised to try and shouldn’t back out now. He finally convinced her to try a taste when told her she could just go spit it out in the bathroom or spit into an empty cup if she really doesn’t like it, he didn’t care if she swallowed or not as long as she didn’t make a mess spitting on the carpet or whatever.

I was almost ashamed to be there in my post orgasmic brain fog, the reality check thoughts were creeping in as whatever little remaining bit of good moral Christian boy still left within me harassed my subconscious. Something about corrupting a little girl like this seemed so infinitely worse than convincing any of the young neighbourhood boys to do all the exact same things. We’d really crossed some kind of line with this one, and there was no going back now.

But these kinds of sane, ethical and rational thoughts never lasted long down in The Dungeon, not with everyone still naked all around me, especially Clara still being so horny and curious about everything. And when she finally gave up arguing with Grant and started sucking his dick, seeing that was all I needed to stay horny. My dick didn’t even get soft, and I was dying to see what Clara would do when Grant blew his load in her mouth. Watching her try and suck Grant’s huge dick with that tiny mouth was unbelievably hot, and she was surprisingly good at it despite having way less experience than any of us.

The two of them didn’t make a big show out of it, Grant just told her he was going to cum and Clara sealed her lips around the head of his cock. She held on and braced herself for it, and she had quite the hilarious shocked look on her face when he finally started squirting. I could see Grant’s dick pulsating and pumping cum directly into her tiny little mouth, and she was in for a bit of a surprise because he could really produce some massive loads. But she didn’t choke or gag or even flinch one bit, she took it like a champ and started swallowing immediately. She was gulping it down as fast as he was pumping it into her mouth, her little throat drinking it down as his cock kept pulsing and pumping more into her mouth.

“Wow, you barely even tasted it,” Grant said to her as he finished up, “holy fuck, you said you weren’t going to swallow!”

“Mmm” she mumbled and gulped as she took his cock out of her mouth. “No, I can definitely taste it,” she said, swallowing the last bits.

“See? It’s not so bad, right?” he asked her.

“I dunno, I guess,” she said with a pondering look on her face, still analyzing the flavor lingering in her mouth. “It’s not that good either,” she went on, wiping her lips and holding back a dry heave, “I can’t believe I just did that, that’s like, really gross and slutty.” It almost looked like instant regret hitting her face as she came to terms with what she just did, so we tried to make sure she wasn’t ashamed of herself.

“So? We all do it, and we’re guys,” Grant reassured her, “it’s not that big of a deal, it didn’t gross you out, did it?”

“Not really, but it tastes fucking weird, and it’s all slimy and sticky,” she replied, kind of sucking her tongue and trying to clear it out of her mouth, “it’s kinda gross, but not that bad I guess,” she said as she reached for a drink to flush it down.

She had pretty much the same reaction a lot of the guys did the first they tasted cum. We had a pretty funny discussion about our first times trying it, and in the end Clara was quite proud of herself for going through with it even though she wasn’t a huge fan of the taste or texture. She made swallowing look so easy that we were all pretty sure that first taste would probably leave her curious and craving more – since she hadn’t immediately gagged or spat it out, her curiosity was bound to leave her wanting another taste eventually.

After that Clara was so horny she wanted to keep taking turns humping us again, so she paired up with Chris and gave him the same pussy grinding outercouse on his bed like she did to me. She mounted him in cowgirl position and slid his cock between her pussy lips and rubbed her clit against it, but carefully controlled her position so there was no way he could actually stick it in. She was probably worried that he was going to try the same trick as I did and slide her up far enough to slip his dick in, because she just stayed in that upright position in full control and didn’t collapse onto his chest like she did on top of me. And that just made it more fun to watch because I could see her pussy squishing and sliding on his cock, and admire her perfect little body as she gyrated and squirmed on top of him. She even grabbed both his hands and pinned them to the floor when he kept trying to grab her by the ass, and she totally just dominated him and kept riding him at her own pace.

Clara started humming and softly moaning again, and she had her second (or third?) orgasm of the night riding Chris’s dick like that. Watching her tense up and squirm as she moved her pussy around and seeing just how long and intense a female orgasm can be was intense, it almost made me jealous I couldn’t cum like that. Not only did she cum like crazy, but Chris started warning her to stop right in the middle of it because he was about to cum too. But Clara wouldn’t or couldn’t let off, she kept grinding him until Chris lost control and started blowing his load. Their orgasms were damn near simultaneous, and laying on his back with his dick smushed against his belly, Chris started shooting ropes of gooey cum all over his body, all the way up to his chest and almost hitting himself in the face. Clara kept sliding her pussy lips up and down his shaft and rubbing her clit on his dick and pumping it out of him, and he shot all over his own body leaving himself completely glazed in his own cum.

Chris could really get some distance with his ejaculations, so it was one of the messier cumshots I’d ever seen, and Clara didn’t even apologize for causing it, she was too busy whimpering and trembling in pure orgasmic ecstasy herself. Chris didn’t seem bothered either because of how ridiculously good it had felt, and both of them were out of breath and didn’t even say anything as she slowly crawled off him and sat on the floor next to him. A couple powerful orgasms in a row like that was usually enough to knock most guys out for the night so I thought Clara would definitely be done with it by then. We’d been at it for quite a while and it was getting pretty late by then, she’d cum at least twice now and the rest of us except Adam had all cum once.

Poor Adam had been a little left out because of his own passive quiet nature, but he was finally getting horny enough to let his freaky perverted side show a lot more. As Chris laid there plastered with his cum all over his belly and chest wondering what to do about it, Adam asked him if he wanted help cleaning it up. Chris wasn’t sure what he meant, and I think we were all quite shocked when Adam crawled on top of Chris and started licking and sucking the cum off his skin. He basically tongue bathed Chris’s naked torso completely clean and ate all his cum right off his body, suddenly acting like an even hungrier cumslut than I was. Licking up cum off each other’s naked bodies like that was a pretty bold and unusual move, we ate plenty of cum right from the tap and didn’t care how gay it was, but this wasn’t just gay it was borderline homoerotic. I mean it still went with the theme of not making a mess, but this was the gayest possible way to clean up. And it just made me more horny and jealous, especially with the way Clara watched him do it, sitting there blushing and smiling and still naked and somehow still horny.

I was ready for one more quick round before bed so I asked Adam if he wanted to swallow my load too, but he said he wanted me to fuck him and told me to cum inside him instead. I happily agreed, we’d all been understandably focused on Clara so much he wasn’t getting the constant fucking he was used to and loved so much, so his last bit of showing off was going to be letting me raw fuck and blow my load into him. Clara did still want to watch after all.

So I eagerly grabbed him and bent him over the coffee table, and I was so horny I couldn’t resist showing off one last dirty thing myself – there was still one thing we hadn’t shown Clara and I guess they were all too chicken to do it in front of her. But I wasn’t anymore so I just bent over and stuck my mouth between Adam’s butt cheeks and started tongue fucking his ass. Clara had teased us with the tantalizing prospect of perhaps trying anal herself but hadn’t really followed through, so all I wanted to do is show her how well practiced we were and how much fun it really is, and shoving my tongue in his ass would hopefully prove it’s not as dirty as she thinks it is. Adam sure loved getting fucked enough that he would hopefully make it look appealing too, so this was as much about putting on a show as getting each other off. This late into the night giving each other rimjobs was the last thing we hadn’t done in front of her, so might as well check that off the list too.

“Woah,” was all Clara quietly whispered as she saw me start making out with Adam’s ass, watching in shock. I pulled his cheeks apart wide and made it really obvious that I was indeed sticking my tongue right up inside him, and I used excessive amounts of spit to really lube him up. “Holy shit,” Clara said, “ok now THAT’S perverted, does that actually feel good or something?”

“Yeah, feels really good,” Adam said to her as I kept tongue fucking him.

“Doesn’t that taste weird? Are you actually sticking your tongue inside him?” She followed up and asked me.

“Yeah,” I said as I came up for air, “doesn’t taste like anything, I don’t care, I’m just making him wet so my dick slides in better,” I went on as I got up into position.

“You really are crazy, that’s crazy,” Clara said still in disbelief, “I can’t believe you just did that.”

“It’s not any worse than sucking someone’s dick after fucking,” I said, justifying my actions and calling her out for going ass to mouth, which she had while going around sucking all our cocks. She didn’t seem too grossed out by it, but she wasn’t her usual curious open minded self about it either.

I spared her any more explanation and just slid my dick inside Adam as she kept watching. I grabbed him by the hips and started pushing long deep slow trusts in and out, feeling his tight hole start to relax. As I got into a slow rhythm and started fucking him properly, I reached around underneath him and started stroking his hard cock to the beat.

Meanwhile Grant was back to being horny again, and as he sat there stroking his cock he started bugging Clara again. While she was sitting there watching me fuck Adam, Grant offered to lick her ass if she wanted to know what it feels like. She wasn’t curious enough to want to find out and told him no way, but that didn’t stop Grant from bringing up her earlier remarks and trying to hold her to it, trying to convince Clara she should let him try fucking her in the ass too. He told her that if she didn’t want to go all the way and have real sex then she should at least try anal instead, but she was even more certain she wasn’t going to allow that. She still didn’t want to try it herself, but that didn’t mean she didn’t love to watch us do it. And at least she said she might try it some other time, hinting that she definitely didn’t want this to be a one time thing, which was a great sign.

So in a last ditch effort to get some more action out of Clara, Gran asked if she was going to try humping him next, but she refused that too, saying she was still too sensitive and needed a break. She promised to try with him too later or some other time to even things out, but she was too worn out to do anything right in that moment. For now all she wanted to do was relax and keeping watching us fuck each other.

So Grant did the next best thing and asked if he could get in on the action with me and Adam. Chris was pretty much knocked out and too busy recovering from his orgasm to help out, Clara only wanted to be our audience, so it made sense to get into some 3-way action with me and Adam, give her one last wild show for the night. I told Grant he should just fuck me while I fuck Adam, and he eagerly agreed and went to get in position behind me. I bent myself over Adam a bit and stopped moving as Grant got into place, and he just lined his dick up and spat a little gob of spit down and rubbed it on my hole, and immediately slid his cock inside me. Being in the middle of a fuck sandwich like that was one of my favourite positions to be in, especially with Grant’s long, thick dick filling me up. The only awkward part was trying to pump and move in a rhythm that works for all 3 us us, so I just let Grant set the pace and let his trusts transmit through me all the way into Adam.

The 3 of us fucked like Clara wasn’t even there, but she was impossible to ignore as she sat there right next to us watching the action. She wasn’t playing with herself anymore but she was still all naked and her pussy was still wet, and after watching us go at it for a good minute or two, she said she had to go pee and got up to leave. She obviously really had to go because she didn’t want to walk out in the middle of the show, she said she’d be right back and told us to hold on and not to stop before she got back. So we kept going at it and had one of those little reality check giggles to ourselves while she was gone. She left the bathroom door open so we heard her peeing and flushing the toilet, and she was back in no time at all. She went and sat down on the sofa right next to where I had Adam bent over the coffee table, still just hanging out totally nude, and she lounged there enjoying the rest of the live gay sex show we put on for her like a little hedonist.

I switched what hand I was using to give Adam a reacharound so Clara could see even better, and as soon as she got back Grant sped up and started fucking me harder and deeper. We really did put on a show for her, and for Chris laying there watching from the other side. I kept looking over at Clara and smiling back at the mischievous grin she had on her still blushing face, admiring her perfect smooth little body, wishing it was her I was fucking instead of Adam. Not that Adam’s hole wasn’t amazingly tight, he was probably my favourite of all to fuck because of how he unashamedly loved it. He even knew how to clench all the right muscles at just the right time, and sliding my cock in and out of him felt so amazing that I came first.

I warned them both that I was going to cum, but Adam told me to keep going, so I told Grant to keep going too. I laid my body down onto Adam’s back and held onto his shoulders for leverage, and I started pumping and setting the pace leaving Grant to just hold on and try to keep his dick still inside me while I thrashed back and forth between them. It sure felt great to alternate between Grant’s dick and Adam’s ass, fucking and getting fucked simultaneously, but it honestly wasn’t even that amazing of an orgasm. I already came once only a little while ago so I didn’t have much energy left in me, but it still felt great as the pulsations started and my dick exploded inside Adam. I pumped a good 8 or 10 gooey squirts deep into his guts, holding on for dear life and freezing in position. Once it was all out of me I told Grant to stop and let me get up, so he slowly pulled his dick out of me at the same time as I pulled out of Adam.

I was so drained by that point that I just slid out from between them and got out of their way, leaving Grant to finish the job and have sloppy seconds inside Adam. With my cum slowly starting to dribble out of Adam’s hole, Grant stepped up and plugged the leak with his cock and started fucking him with my load in there lubing it up for him. He gave Adam a reacharound too and actually made him cum first, but Adam never told him to stop, he just kind of collapsed and relaxed and let Grant have his way with him anyway. It didn’t take long for Grant to cum too, and he blew his load deep inside Adam and mixed it in there with mine, leaving his gaped little hole quite a mess by the time he pulled out.

We were all exhausted by then, and Grant told Clara that’s it, show’s over, time to got to bed for real this time. Adam got up and waddled into the bathroom to clean himself up and rearrange his guts back to normal, Chris and I were already crawled into bed, so Grant started setting his bed up on the floor too and handed Clara her pj’s, basically kicking her out. She was still disappointed she couldn’t sleep in the same room and hang out naked with us anymore, but she understood the danger of getting caught out there with us in the morning if we slept in. We did actually need at least a few hours of sleep, so she really had no choice and had to close herself off in Grant’s bedroom like we promised. So she grabbed her stuff and slowly reluctantly walked backwards into Grant’s room as we all said goodnight and took one last good long look at each other’s naked bodies.

She shut the door and we all went to bed and didn’t even say anything. I think we were all a little too shocked by what had just happened to even talk about it, plus even if we whispered to ourselves Clara would probably still hear us talking about her. So we just killed all the lights and crawled into our sleeping bags and under our blankets, still nude like we always did, and the only thing we discussed were our plans for the next day as we tried to drift off to sleep.

But it sure took a while to actually fall asleep as we lay there trying to process everything we’d just seen and done together. It was definitely going to be an interesting mood waking up there the next morning, and I couldn’t wait to see what other wild stuff this was going to lead to.

Clara was obviously too much of pervert to make this a one time thing, if she actually moved to our neighbourhood or ever just slept over again, she definitely struck me as the type to become another full time member of our secret club, girl or not. I still didn’t know her well enough to be certain she was 100% trustworthy, but that wasn’t a concern – I didn’t trust some of the boys in the club half as much as I trusted her, and that never stopped me before. Some of those other guys we knew also had their own stories about experimenting with girls kind of like how Grant and Clara started, so maybe what had just happened wasn’t all that far fetched after all. We all heard the stories of young teenage sluts putting out and it wasn’t unheard of for girls as young as 13 & 14 to be getting pregnant in that trashy low rent neighbourhood, so I guess slutty girls like that gotta start somewhere, right? Did we just create one of our very own? Only time would tell.

That night obviously getting her pregnant never even crossed any of our minds and wasn’t remotely a concern. Not only was she not going to let any of us actually fuck her, she was only 11 years old and so pre-pubescent we just assumed she was physically still too young to even get pregnant. She was obviously more concerned about it than us, because the whole fake “I’m still a virgin as long as you don’t stick it in” thing was such transparent bullshit. But we could relate because we were so full of shit too, and her bullshit fed into out own bullshit because we were all heavily lying to ourselves and each other in various different ways. If Clara can fool around with 4 guys at a bisexual orgy and it doesn’t meant that she’s a dirty slut, then we can do whatever we want among us guys and it doesn’t mean we’re faggots either. No one but ourselves can judge us for what we do in secret, so I doesn’t count against our reputations and we can still pretend to be all straight and innocent, as long as no one ever finds out.

The next morning we all totally slept in after staying up pretty late the night before. It was uncommon for all of us to still be out cold and get woken up by Grant’s mom coming downstairs, so it was good that Clara was sleeping alone in Grant’s room like we promised when she came down to wake us up.

This was the awkward part about sleeping naked, just laying there hiding in my sleeping bag as Grant’s mom walked into the room. Normally we were up and about long before anyone would come downstairs to check on us in the mornings, but that was one of the risks we took and it occasionally made for a weird and uncomfortable wake up call whenever we slept in. She stepped around all of us to go knock on Grant’s door and check on Clara, and after waking her up too she told us to make ourselves decent and come up for breakfast, almost like she knew we weren’t wearing our pj’s under our blankets and sleeping bags. I’m sure she was attentive enough to realize we slept nude at some point, she wasn’t totally clueless and our shirtlessness and shyness to get out of bed surely gave us away. But even if she did realize it she sure didn’t seem to care one bit, she never said anything about it or made it awkward and always left relatively quickly so we could get changed in peace. As motherly as she was sometimes, she respected our privacy and knew she wasn’t really welcome to just hang out down in The Dungeon, so she thankfully kept her visits and intrusions to a respectful minimum.

We all started crawling out of bed and Clara got to see all of us naked again as she opened the door to Grant’s room and casually walked in on us before we had a chance to put our clothes on. After being woken from a pretty deep sleep none of us had the usual morning wood we normally woke up with, so I think it was the first time she actually saw any of our dicks totally soft as she casually said good morning, looking around at all of us and our flaccid dicks. She was back to wearing her long girly nighty and politely asked us if we wanted some privacy to get changed, but after everything that happened the night before we weren’t the least bit shy around her and none of us cared if she wanted to watch us put our clothes on. She was got all happy when we told her she can look all she wants, and she even left the door to Grant’s room open so we could watch her strip naked and get changed too.

As we got up we didn’t even talk much about what had transpired the night before. Not that any of us felt guilty or ashamed or even that awkward about it, we all had a bit of that happy morning-after glow and there just wasn’t all that much to say about it other than how much fun it was and how we all wanted to do it again sometime. We all definitely agreed on that, and even Clara was desperate to plan another sleepover so we could have another orgy again asap. She couldn’t wait to spend another night in The Dungeon with us, especially if Matt and Jay would be cool with her joining our little club too. She was as disappointed as we were that the two of them had left early and missed out on all the real fun that night, so she told us we should definitely tell them what happened, as long as they don’t go blabbing about it to anyone else.

We really had made Clara feel pretty special in some sick and twisted way by letting her in on our big secret sex club, and that morning she reassured us she’d never tell anyone about any of it, especially if we kept letting her in on the action whenever she wants and we never told anyone what a dirty slut she really is. It almost sounded like a blackmail threat, like she’d rat us out if we kicked her out and didn’t let her have her way with us, but that was an easy deal to make even though I didn’t think she really meant it that way.

The only problem was we didn’t even know when we’d be seeing her again. Clara was heading off for another day of house hunting with her mom right after breakfast, and they’d be going straight back home to farm country after that. They were bound to visit again soon at least a few times before they found a place to actually move to, but there was no set timeline for any of that, so it really sucked saying goodbye to Clara after breakfast and not knowing when we’d see her again.

🔞 Candy.AI 🔥 AI Sex Chat - Roleplay, Erotic Stories, Try for Free 🕹️

Please, Rate This Story:

(average: 3.00 out of 4 votes)