Kaylee’s gymnastics captain

Kaylee’s gymnastics captain stays the night.

So this weekend didn’t go quite like I originally hoped. But Kaylee surprised me with some role-playing Saturday morning/afternoon.

So Kaylee said she was coming over with friend after gymnastics practice. I had a nice simple dinner planned, and was hoping for some more time with Hannah. She called and told me I didn’t have to pick her up. Beth was driving her home. Beth is a junior in high school, and is a team captain at her gymnastics club.

They showed up about 6:30 PM. I was surprised to see that Beth was the one staying over, as Kaylee is only in 8th grade. They both looked amazing, Kaylee said that they had a few parts of her (Kaylee’s) routine they wanted to work on tonight and tomorrow morning.

I made tenderloins and fries for dinner. Not knowing Beth didn’t eat carbs. (Hannah loves tenderloins) no pun intended. So I tossed a salad together for Beth.

I gave them their space after dinner. So they could practice in backyard. While i cleaned up. Watching them both from kitchen window. Beth was definitely a gifted athlete. She was walking on her hands with one leg bent forward and one backwards. I was getting worked up…

So I originally was hoping for a diffrent outcome to this evening. But who can complain about two beautiful teen girls turning cartwheels and dancing in the backyard.

After practice they both took a quick shower. And we watched a Movie *Casper. Then they went to bed both girls slept in Kaylee’s room. So I was alone for 1st time in awhile, other than when Kaylee was at her mothers or Hannah’s. I was laying in bed, 2 beautiful girls just across the hallway. I obviously was very horny. I didn’t want to simply rub one out. I tapped on Kaylee’s door no answer. I open door and whisper Kaylee are you awake? No answer. Now Kaylee always sleeps on the right side, even when Hannah visits she normally sleep in middle next to me. I went over to the rifht side of her full sized bed. I saw a brunette hair so i assumed it was Kaylee and kissed her on forehead and placed hand on her thigh, slightly shaking to wake her. I asked can you come into hallway, I need a favor. (Was hoping for a quickie or a blowjob)

Well it wasn’t her, it was Beth! She sat up can I help you? Waking Kaylee, who was quite shocked. I told her I am sorry Kaylee always sleeps on this side of the bed. I needed to ask her a question.

Do you always wake your daughter by rubbing on her upper thigh? She normally is difficult to wake up. And how she sleeps her legs are normally in that area. Thankfully Beth seemed to understand. Kaylee came out into hallway with me. I apologized to her as well. She asked what I wanted. I told her nevermind I was way to embarrassed at this point. Go back to bed hope you can get some sleep.

When they finally woke up in the morning. I had breakfast ready. Waffles sausage, bacon, eggs and mandarin oranges (Hannah’s favorires). Beth reminded me she doesn’t eat carbs. She ate sausage eggs and a piece of bacon.

After breakfast they were out back again, this time Beth was in shorts. I tried not to stare, but I am a guy. After they were done Beth hugs Kaylee. Tells her she is doing great, keep practicing that routine, she will certainly make the High School team when she becomes a freshman. Remember to keep stretching to stay limber. (I can help her with that one)*wink

After Beth left, Kaylee asked me if I was trying to creep on Beth last night. I assured her I was trying to wake her (Kaylee) up, to sneak into my room for a quickie. She said I am pathetic, probably true.

Kaylee then asked what I would of done if Beth was receptive to my touch.

I picked her up brought her into her room. Laid her on bed i placed my hand on her thigh. She sits up and says shhhh don’t wake Kaylee, I was hoping you would show up tonight. She grabbed my hand and raised it up to her already wet panty covered vagina. I whispered to her thankfully Kaylee is a sound sleeper. I started kissing on her while rubbing her slit over her panties. She let out a soft moan. I then raised her shirt over her breast and took one in my mouth. I imagine that they are considerably larger, like Beth’s. “Beth” we can’t get caught doing this please come into the living room. I grab her hand she follows me down the hall to living room. Can’t take her to the room Kaylee and I normally share, or she would see many of her items in there, and possibly get suspicious.

In living room I lay a blanket over the couch. And i would slowly remove hers cloths. I would kiss every inch of her body. Just like this.. Kaylee “Beth” is so wet in anticipation. I then remove my clothes Kaylee “Beth” immediately started going down on me as I had two fingers in her vagina. I found her gspot and started rubbing it quickly and firmly bringing her to a quick wet orgasm. Thankfully I laid that blanket down. I would then start going down on Beth. Kaylee is nearing another orgasmic bliss (Kaylee does not normally have orgasms so close together) . OMG I love older guys she would soon state way to loudly shh dont wake up Kaylee. With my boyfriend I am lucky to get 1 orgasm. That one was the best I have ever had. I am nearing my own orgasm and “Beth” sences this and stops. I want you to cum in me. So I place myself at her vagina and push myself into her. She is still so tight. She puts her legs behind her head and I make love to her. Very slowly, faster she pleads. But I want to savor this moment. How often will I get to make love to a “different” teen. I do finally pick up the pace. I trust rapidly and mercilessly into her “16” year old pussy. “Beth” is digging her nails into my ass pulling me into her on every thrust (hmm Kaylee has never done that before). She wrapped her legs around me and has another orgasm. I press myself as far as I can go and cum into her. “Beth” don’t be nervous I have had a vasectomy, you will not get pregnant. Kaylee said I am sure she is on birth control. I know she has sex with her boyfriend. She went into bathroom to clean herself up. “Beth” asks if we could sleep here holding her for a bit, before she returns to Kaylee’s room. I would of set alarm for 2 hours and woken her to return to my daughter’s room. But she is Kaylee again. I wrap us up in the blanket. Great I get the wet spot oh well so worth it.

God I love you Kaylee. That was incredible!

I love you too daddy.

And we take an afternoon nap in each others arms on the couch.

My daughter Kaylee at only 13 years old, yet she is already the best lover I have ever had.

🔞 Candy.AI 🔥 AI Sex Chat - Roleplay, Erotic Stories, Try for Free 🕹️

Please, Rate This Story:

(average: 4.59 out of 32 votes)