Playing With Dicks – How boyhood experiments turn into teenage degeneracy – Chapter 05

Chapter 5 – The Club – What happens when we discover more friends with the same secrets? We lose control of the situation and it gets even wilder.

WARNING: For patient readers only!

PLAYING WITH DICKS is a very long novel, for context please go back and start reading from chapter 1, you will be lost if you try to pick up the story from here. Or skip ahead to the recap at the beginning of the next part, this novel is divided into standalone parts with recaps to catch up in between.

Playing With Dicks

How boyhood experiments turn into teenage degeneracy

Chapter 5 – The Club

We had to make sure we snuck off without anyone else noticing and stayed well hidden, but we didn’t want to take them all the way down to our spot in the ravine, so we took off toward our next favourite spot hidden beside the RV parking lot. We reaffirmed our pact of secrecy and made double sure that Grant and Chris knew the consequences if this secret ever got out, and they swore never to tell a soul what we were about to reveal to them.

As soon as we got there we finally just told them – we said we’d been sneaking off to play with our dicks and masturbate together. We tried to play it off all casual like it’s not even gay and isn’t a huge deal, and their reaction was absolutely priceless. Grant gave Chris a friendly but hard punch in the shoulder and said something along the lines of “See! I told you so! I knew it!” as the two of them smiled and almost laughed at us, but not in a mean spirited way. Not at all the reaction we expected, but they were shockingly positive about it, like they were hearing exactly what they expected and hoped for. They seemed surprised and excited and curious, not at all weirded out by it and that was a good sign. Matt and Jay and I were all dumbfounded by what Grant said, so we just had to ask – what exactly did he mean that he knew it all along? How in the hell did he have such an accurate suspicion and figure us out like that? How in living fuck did he know already?!

Grant said that it was kind of obvious from how sneaky and secretive we’d been about it for so long – what else could we be so terribly worried about anyone finding out? He said he’d pretty much figured it out but didn’t want to say anything about it in case it got awkward, so he was blown away that we were voluntarily confirming all his suspicions. It still didn’t make sense that this would be his automatic assumption, and his explanation was a little suspicious itself. I had a brief internal panic as I wondered who else might be putting 2 and 2 together and having frighteningly accurate suspicions about us, but suddenly I didn’t give a shit when I realized what this actually meant. There was only one logical reason why their minds would go straight into the gutter and assume what they did, and their reactions gave them away. There was no way they were all innocent if the two of them had been off discussing and theorizing such thing about us and our big secret.

Suddenly I was convinced that this might not be their first foray into some mutual masturbation of their own, or maybe more – there’s just no way they could have guessed what we were up to if they hadn’t experimented the same way a little themselves, or at least thought about it. And if they hadn’t yet, then they were at least pretty damn dirty minded and curious if that was their automatic go-to assumption, so we’d obviously made the right decision picking them as new recruits. Not only had they accurately guessed what our big secret was, they seemed overjoyed to have their crazy suspicions confirmed right from the horse’s mouth. They were shocked to hear it, that’s for sure, but they didn’t have the awkward or grossed out reaction you’d expect from innocently homophobic boys at that age. It was so weird – either it was yet another insanely lucky coincidence that the two of them were already dirty like-minded perverts, or this homosexual experimentation thing was way more common and secretly accepted among guys than we ever imagined. Maybe no one talks about it because everyone is actually secretly doing it.

So far this was going better that we ever could have hoped. We never thought to suspect any of our other friends of being as perverted as we were, but now I didn’t know what to think after the two of them got so excited about the idea of “playing with dicks”. My only worry was that if Grant and Chris had accurately guessed what we’d been up to in secret, maybe all our other friends had made the same assumptions and already knew what our big secret is. Maybe there were already rumours circulating about us, but maybe that wasn’t a bad thing.

I decided to turn Grant’s reaction around on them and straight up asked why they assumed what they did and how the hell did they know what we were up to? I was heavily implying that they were at least as bad of perverts or faggots as any of us for even thinking about it, hoping I was right to assume something similar about them. Why else react the way they did if they hadn’t at least thought about getting into some naughty gay mischief together? The fact that the two of them reached that conclusion together meant they’d been theorizing about our big secret and talking about us behind our backs, so what was their deal?

Grant and Chris played coy and didn’t really know what to say, they were probably still too shocked by our confession. But they were clearly surprised in a good way, almost too good to be true, and I thought I knew why. Since they seemed so unexpectedly excited about what our big secret was, we straight up asked them if they ever did anything similar before on their own. We told them that since they now knew our deepest darkest secret, if they were hiding anything remotely similar now was the time to tell us. Tit for tat, we had to keep things fair and even and now it was their turn to tell us whatever their deepest darkest secret was.

The two of them hung back and huddled together, whispering to each other so we couldn’t hear them. It was kind of rude, but my heart started to race because it was a good sign – they were both smiling mischievously and whispering like they definitely had a secret of their own. It was obvious they were either debating whether to tell us or not, or they were getting their story straight before making something up, and I couldn’t wait to hear what they had to say.

What happened next was the best possible surprise we could have hoped for, and quickly proved what a great idea expanding our little club could be. Grant and Chris kept grinning like idiots, and after their little whisper conference they told us they’d been doing the exact same thing for years now – this wasn’t their first time playing with dicks together! What we were up to was nothing new or novel to them, almost like it was not a big deal and a “well duh” kind of moment. They were almost proud to admit they’d been masturbating together ever since their parents got together and moved them into the same bedroom for a while, before we ever met them, before they even moved into the house they lived in now. They’d been at it way longer than we had, and still kept it up even though they lived in a bigger house with separate bedrooms now. It was amazing – what a coincidence that they really were perverts exactly like us, just like we had hoped. Not only that, but the way they bragged about jacking off together was like they were almost trying to one-up us and our little secret, like as if their secret thing was cooler and better than ours, and they might have had a point. This was going way better than we expected, and we almost didn’t know how to handle it or what to say to them. It was just such a shock to suddenly realize that we weren’t alone in the devious kind of fun we liked to have, and it was almost too good to be true. We’d been hoping for a reaction exactly like this, and it was hard to believe it was actually happening.

So we all started excitedly swapping stories about how and why we got into our different versions of sexual mischief in the first place. Our stories started almost exactly the same, sleeping together in the same room and not having the privacy to rub one out before falling asleep. For us it was purely for the mischievous fun of it right from the start, but for them it basically started out of necessity because they had to share a room for a while and pretty much had no choice. When the choice is between jacking off in the same room as your step brother or not jacking off at all, it’s not really even a decision for boys at that age. They both tried to hide it from each other at first until they realized it’s not only easier to just be open and honest about it, but having someone else to do it with actually makes it even more fun.

All the excuses and justifications we had for our devious desires were almost identical, and we’d simultaneously but separately made that discovery of how much more fun jacking off can be with friends. It was cathartic to realize that neither of our little groups were alone in our secrets, and none of us were really prepared for it. And after that initial confession, none of us knew exactly how far the others had taken it – all we admitted to at first was only jacking off together which may or may not have even implied hand jobs as well. We didn’t know if Grant and Chris had tried sucking dick like we had, or if they’d gone even further, but none of us were really admitting it yet. I wished I just had the guts to ask them, but I was way too nervous even as we traded confessions. Better to take it slow and see how things go when we actually get our dicks out.

We finally all pulled our dicks out and started jerking off while traded stories about how we initially got started and what our first times masturbating together were like. This was crazy how well it was going, again we were in one of those unbelievable situations actually fulfilling what was supposed to be just a wild fantasy. There we were jacking off with two more friends who seemed just as horny and eager as we were, and there was still no telling how far things might go with them. It was one of those weird reality check moments where we couldn’t even believe what we were doing as we were doing it.

As I stood there slowly stroking my dick I stared at Grant and Chris, marveling at their decent sized dicks. They were both almost the same age as me so they were about as well developed, and Grant’s dick looked almost bigger than mine. Both of them were intact and uncircumcised just like us, and all five of us took good long looks at each other’s dicks as we stood there slowly stroking ourselves. It was so much fun and such a huge rush of adrenaline that it felt almost as exciting as our first time all over again, and our new recruits were definitely getting a kick out of it as much as we were. This was nothing any of us hadn’t done before, but the excitement of merging our two separate groups together into one big circle jerk really was almost too good to be true. We had more in common than I thought, and I wondered what else Grant and Chris had been up to and if they’d been plotting and planning or just fantasizing about something like this exactly as we had.

The longer we stood there masturbating the more tempted I was getting to ask them if they ever tried anything more than just jerking off together. The more I stared at their hard dicks the more I wanted to stroke or even suck them and really blow their minds, but I had no idea how to even suggest it. They’d been so eager to join our little circle jerk that I was pretty sure they’d be open to a little more dirty experimentation, and if they’d been doing this kind of stuff for years like they said, then there was no telling how far they might have gone already. For all we knew they’d been sucking and fucking even longer than us, but they weren’t volunteering any dirtier confessions and I was still way too nervous to bring it up. Times like this was when I almost got sick of being kind of the unofficial ringleader of this whole adventure, I really wished it wasn’t always up to me to ask all the big questions and make all the bold suggestions. Matt and Jay had picked up the slack a little bit recently, but I definitely wasn’t expecting either of our two new recruits to be brave enough to suggest anything.

So it was a shocking and pleasant surprise when Grant didn’t even hesitate to ask us if we ever tried giving each other handjobs instead of just jerking off in front of each other. He must have had a pretty good hunch that the answer was yes, or he wouldn’t ask us so blatantly and confidently, and after a quick surprised pause the three of us admitted that hell yes we had! We told them like yeah, duh, that was actually the whole point – it feels so much better when someone else does it for you so of course we’d been jerking each other off. The biggest shock was how Grant seemed suddenly even less shy than us about it, and he and Chris totally agreed with us and confessed they did it too, using the same justification that it feels way better than stroking yourself, and we all admitted it like as if that’s what we meant all along talking about jerking off together. I guess it really was implied from our initial confession because we all knew exactly where this was headed, and now it was all out in the open. We still weren’t admitting to any of the dirtier stuff, but the way we talked about it feeling better when someone else does it for you left the whole thing very open ended.

It was that awesome mix of nervous and exciting that I was starting to really enjoy, and actually admitting these dirty things and was actually easier than I thought it would be. They wanted to trade handjobs and make it into a real circle jerk as badly as we did, and by then that shouldn’t have even been a surprise anymore. We just never expected them to be this eager to join in on the fun, but considering they had their own taboo history together it all made sense. We weren’t so much recruiting new members into our club as we were merging two separate secret groups together, and that unexpected surprise really did make it way easier and way more exciting than expected. We weren’t the only ones after all, so we didn’t have to feel so weird about it anymore.

There was also the fact that the two of them had been fooling around together for much longer than we had, and for all we knew they might have even been way more experienced than us in ways we never imagined. Seeing as they were just as curious and perverted as us and had about a year long head start, then there was no telling how far they might have gone, literally having every single night to fool around at home instead of just the odd sleepover on weekends. Maybe we were the ones getting suckered into something even crazier than our own tame little secret adventure, and we really had no idea what we were getting ourselves into. Who’s secret was actually worse, and who was actually leading who here? All we knew was that this expansion of our secret club was going way better than we ever dreamed it would so far, so we absolutely had to make the best of it even though we had no idea what this was going to lead to.

Without a lick of hesitation all five of us tightened up our little circle so we could reach over and stroke each other’s dicks. We were almost giggling with excitement as we reached over to grab each other’s shafts, all in total agreement about the taboo thrill and without a hint of homophobic awkwardness as we started pleasuring each other’s cocks. This definitely wasn’t Grant’s and Chris’s first time fooling around, they got right into it like they belonged there, and they were as good at giving handjobs as any of us. This wasn’t anything any of us hadn’t done before, but it was inexplicably more exciting now with all 5 of us doing it at the same time. Taking advantage of the added numbers, we switched directions and swapped places a bunch of times until we all had a try with everyone, and Grant and Chris definitely agreed that it’s good to keep everything even and fair.

This was exactly what all five of us had been hoping would happen, and it was still a total shock that Grant and Chris were so much like us. We never would have guessed that the two of them were already fooling around on their own, yet they’d somehow managed to see right through us and correctly assumed we were a bunch of perverts. But since they so fortuitously turned out to be little perverts too it was so awesome to have them joining in and combining our secrets together into one big club. Either it was just an amazingly lucky coincidence that the first two friends we shared our secret with had a similar secret of their own, or maybe the kind of sexual experimentation we were into might actually be a lot more common than we imagined. It was exciting and almost scary to think that maybe Grant and Chris might even be worse perverts than us, which was a distinct possibility given their head start and longer experience than us. Maybe the curiosity and open mindedness that got us this far wasn’t super rare and maybe the five of us weren’t the only boys our age already starting to fool around. After all with such a relatively normal upbringing and surrounded by all the same cultural cues as everyone, we couldn’t be totally unique in our perverted desires. Maybe underage sex was a lot more common than anyone could imagine, even before teenage, only you never hear about it because it’s mostly young friends like us doing gay shit in secret just for the fun of it. I mean if any of us had been getting lucky with girls at that age we’d be bragging about getting laid to everyone we knew, but this secret degenerate faggotry was fun for a whole different set of reasons and wasn’t something to go bragging about. But somehow that degeneracy and secrecy just made it even more fun.

My mind was a blur as we stood there jacking each other off in every combo we could. I was suddenly so excited thinking that maybe even more guys would want to join in and our secret club would get even bigger, but at the same time I was still worried and wondering exactly where Grant and Chris would draw the line. They seemed so damn eager to join in but we still didn’t know if they’d tried anything more than some mutual masturbation, and none of us were too eager to bring that up right away even though we were dying to know. We were having enough fun just stroking each other’s dicks in a big circle and watching all the action – it was like the opening scene to some epic gay porn, only nobody knew where it would all end up.

Despite having so much in common, we were still hiding a lot from them and maybe they were hiding something too – maybe they outpaced us in other ways. The fact that they were step-brothers made it kind of weird I guess, barely escaping it being incest on a technicality, and there could be anything else we didn’t know yet. Maybe they already did stuff with other kids, older teens, maybe even with girls – or worse, maybe one or both of them was molested or something insane like that. It definitely wasn’t unheard of in that white trash neighbourhood those days, and there had to be some explanation for their obvious indecent proclivities. We had our excuses, so what were theirs? I just hoped that whatever it was didn’t make things awkward and the whole experience stayed positive for everyone.

Thankfully that’s pretty much where the conversation was headed anyway as we kept on playing with each other’s dicks. We kept on trading stories about how we first started and what motivated such taboo sexual transgressions in the first place, we shared and agreed on all our excuses why it wasn’t even gay, and I felt almost absent from the conversation. With 5 of us there I felt less like the leader and more like a bystander than ever before, just going along because I almost didn’t know what to say. Matt and Jay and I stupidly only gave them an abridged version of our story, only lying if you count lying by omission. We told them about our sleepovers and playing truth or dare and how that turned into regularly jerking off together, we told them about all our secret hiding spots we’d been sneaking off to and how we fooled around as often as possible. We left it open ended but stopped just short of telling them about giving each other blowjobs or humping each other at sleepovers.

Tit for tat they told us how they started when Chris caught Grant red handed jerking off one night back when they shared a bedroom, and they’d been doing it together ever since. No creepy molestation story, no weird uncle, just innocent curiosity like us and a lot more private time to act on it. Grant perked up and said they’ve been sneaking into each other’s rooms in the new house late at night “to have all kinds of fun” as he put it, leaving it so obviously open ended that he was obviously hinting there’s more they aren’t telling us. There was this weird vibe in the air, like we all wanted to brag about how far we’d gone and one-up each other’s stories to claim the title of biggest perverts, but it was impossibly awkward with none of us knowing exactly how far the other group had taken things.

Jay instantly picked up on it, and I guess he wanted to cause a stir because he instantly asked Grant what he meant by “all kinds of fun” – like, did he mean that they tried anything more than just jacking off? It felt just like the first time with the original trio all over again, trying to convince each other to try “other stuff” and not being able to just say it. They both blushed and snickered at the rather bold but understandable question, but instead of answering Grant asked why he wants to know – he just turned the question back around on us and asked us if we ever tried anything more than jacking off. We definitely weren’t planning on telling them so much so quickly, but it was so weird how easily we’d gotten to this point. Obviously we could trust them now, and I didn’t even think we’d gross them out with a full confession of every single dirty sex act we’d done. They were obviously hiding something too and were probably just as bad us, and it became a little game to see who’d start bragging about being the biggest perverts first. It was pretty funny the childish way we danced around the topic.

“You tell first!”

“No, you tell first! Why would you even ask?”

“Do you WANT to try other stuff – is that why you want to know?”

“You’re the one who bought it up!”

“No you did, you totally hinted at it!”

“Have you ever tried anything more gay than this or not?”

“…So what if we did? What would you say if we *theoretically* said yes? Then what!?”

It got to the point that it was like okay already – cut the shit, we’re obviously all still hiding something so it’s time to come clean and just admit exactly how far we’ve all taken things in our separate little groups. Surprisingly it was Grant who took the lead again, he looked at Chris like he needed his permission to say it, then he finally confessed that the two of them had tried sucking dick and liked it. He was ready to give it a whole sales pitch and tell us why it’s not actually gay and feels real good, but there was no need for it, I told him we’d been doing the same thing too! They were both as surprised and happy to hear it as we were, none of us could believe we’d been doing the same thing separately all this time. I wanted to keep the momentum going and ask if they’d tried fucking each other, but I was still too scared to say it, and I figured they’d volunteer that information if they wanted to.

Like they still had to prove it or something, Grant immediately kneeled down in front of his step brother and started sucking his dick, clearly with a lot of skill and zero shame. I couldn’t believe he was so eager to show off, and I didn’t want to be one-upped so I got down in front of Jay and started sucking his dick like it was a contest or something. Then Grant and Chris traded places, both of them smiling mischievously at us as Chris started blowing Grant. So I switched over to Matt and started sucking him off, and we all took turns back and forth a bit, and all watching each other intently.

It was wild seeing the two of them trade such skillful blowjobs, and I was so jealous how they’d been doing it for so much longer than us, lucky step bros pleasing each other orally every night. Honestly I was almost a little scared that I might not stay the unofficial ringleader of this little circus, Grant was barely a bit older than me but he seemed to be even less shy and more of a pervert than I was. Chris was a bit more of a quiet one but he sucked dick just as enthusiastically as any of us, and his was the first dick I sucked when we started trading off between our little groups. It was so exciting to have another brand new dick in my mouth, bigger than Matt’s or Jay’s, pretty much same size as mine.

Grant’s was even bigger, and when he got rock hard it looked almost disproportionate on his young little body, easily around 6 inches already, not bad for being barely 12 years old. It almost made me gag stuffing his girthy head into the back of my mouth, and I still couldn’t believe we’d taken it this far so quickly. We’d only snuck away just a few minutes ago, and there we were all patiently taking turns swapping blowjobs until we’d all had a try with everyone, loving every second of it. What unbelievable good luck and what a creepy coincidence that the two guys we picked to recruit into our club had been doing it longer than we had, who was even recruiting who here?

I was still half expecting and really hoping Grant and Chris still had more dirty things to confess, because maybe not being the leader anymore might be worth it if they knew how to fuck and could teach us. But we barely said a word to each other with so much dick in our mouths, and we kept trading blowjobs in 2 pairs while the 5th guy would keep an eye out and make sure the coast is clear. All of us were skilled enough that it didn’t take long to start edging each other, and we’d cycle through and switch spots if anyone got too close. None of us actually wanted to cum that quick, we were having way too much fun. But we were all so horny and worked up we could only last so long.

One after another we sucked each other off to completion, having crazy good orgasms right in the mouth, unassisted. Thankfully both Grant and Chris hadn’t hit puberty hard enough to shoot any cum yet either, but it wouldn’t be out of the question at that age. Grant at least seemed to be a little further ahead in his development, but his orgasm was dry too. Luckily just like us, neither him or Chris felt any kind of shame or regret in that post-orgasm refractory period either, and all 5 of us were left feeling nothing but smugly satisfied with ourselves. If anything we were actually quite proud of ourselves for being so honest and trusting with our friends that having this kind of taboo fun was even an option. Who would have thought that expanding our little secret club would have gone so surprisingly well? It was definitely so much fun that the only regret was not doing this sooner, as usual. To think that we could have been fooling around right along with Grant and Chris all this time, or that we could have started out even younger like they had – it just confirmed what a great idea this whole adventure was, and it seriously fueled our appetite for even more kinky fun. All that time wasted not fooling around even sooner was about to be made up for and then some.

As we quickly wrapped things up and started walking back to the playgrounds, we were unbelievably excited about the possibilities from there on. Not only did we just merge our secret club with Grant and Chris, the five of us were all of a sudden discussing the possibility of recruiting even more friends to join in. If five guys made it more fun, just imagine how awesome it would be with six or seven or ten or more! It didn’t seem feasible when it was just me, Matt and Jay dreaming of a giant circle jerk club, but considering how easily and enthusiastically Grant and Chris joined in, it suddenly felt like anything was possible. We knew plenty of other guys who we assumed would be perverted enough to want to join in, and the more guys that ended up being into it the easier it would be to justify it all in our minds. We’d feel a lot less like faggots or freaks if this was all a pretty normal thing among guys our age, so we really hoped we wouldn’t be the only ones who got such a kick out of it. After the unexpected surprise of finding out how perverted Grant and Chris already were (and vise-versa them finding out about us), we all honestly thought that pretty much every guy probably had the same secret gay fantasies and would jump at an opportunity like this. Matt and Jay and I might have been too geeky to get away with it on our own, but Grant and Chris were cool and popular enough to lend this gay experimentation thing some street cred.

The real questions were who among our friends was actually trustworthy enough to be let in on such a huge secret, and who might already be enough of a sexual deviant to understand how much fun a secret gay sex club could be. Hopefully we’d find out that at least some other friends were already fooling around in secret like Grant and Chris or our original trio, because that would definitely make expanding the club a whole lot easier if it could go remotely as well as the merger of our 2 groups. But we weren’t sure if any of our friends would already be as perverted as us, and we realized that if we really did want to recruit more fresh meat into the circle then we might actually have to convince some virgin newbies to try something something quite taboo. As cool as it would be if all our friends were already faggots like us, introducing some first-timers to it also had to be an option, and might even be more fun if they’re open minded enough. We had to be prepared to deal with innocent and inexperienced but curious first-timers, or with guys that might be just as experienced us, or anywhere in between. We really had no idea what the appetite for some secret homoerotic activities would be among the rest of our friends, but we were dead set on finding out. Even if it was just a remote possibility of making the club even bigger than it already was, it was definitely worth pursuing.

We’d never been so excited about all our secret adventures as we were that day when Grant and Chris joined in. After that amazing session of jerking and sucking each other off we knew things were going to be even more fun from there on out. As we snuck out of our hiding spot and melted back into the crowd of kids playing outside we already planned on doing it all over again as soon and as often as possible. We also re-affirmed our pact of absolute secrecy, only now with the one added caveat that we could tell certain friends if we deemed them trustworthy enough and if we were sure enough they’d want to join in. It was a risky idea for sure, not knowing how guys would react, worrying that someone might snitch if the wrong person found out – but all the risk taking involved in something so taboo was a huge part of the thrill. As long as we were smart and careful about it we’d be fine, all we had to do was introduce the idea slowly and gradually. Don’t tell anyone too many details off the bat, extract a promise of secrecy before revealing the dirty truth, and most importantly maintain a level of plausible deniability until trustworthiness is proven. Only then and only if they seemed interested after we maybe hint at it a bit, that’s when we could show off a bit and spill the beans. It seemed like a genius plan and we hoped it was going to be as surprisingly successful as our first little expansion.

The other big plan we had was to try and throw together the big slumber party over at Grant and Chris’s house. We really hoped all our parents would be okay with it, and since summer was upon us we thought our chances were good given all the looser schedules and more freedom that 2 months off school brings. It really would be amazing to have all night for all five of us to fool around – it would make for one hell of an orgy with so many possibilities in such a large group, and if we were ever going to try and take the next step and go all the way, a sleepover was the best chance for that.

As we all went our separate ways later that day, we all rushed home to ask our parents if we could have a big sleepover party over at Grant’s and Chris’s house. My parents said it was fine as long I wasn’t asking to have them all stay over at our place – having 4 friends over for the night was a bit much in our little apartment, but they didn’t care if we did it at someone else’s place. I was so stoked about it and I really hoped everyone else’s parents would be just as cool about it. A few phone calls later we hashed out all the details and confirmed that indeed all our parents were totally okay with it – even Grant’s and Chris’s parents didn’t mind the idea of all 3 of us sleeping over there, they apparently had more than enough space, and the plan was set in motion. The next Saturday would be the big night, and we all were looking forward to it more than anything.

But things quickly escalated and almost got out of hand before that Saturday even came. The very next day I when I went outside to meet up with the guys again, Grant, Chris, Jay and Matt were already eagerly waiting for me in the yard by my apartment. And in tow along with them they had 2 other friends of ours, James and Brent, younger kids I’d barely ever hung out with. They didn’t even have to say anything, from the looks on everyone’s faces I knew that Grant had already picked these two out as our next recruits. Both of them were barely 10 years old, and I couldn’t remember if they were in Matt and Jay’s class at school or one grade below. They’d gotten as far as promising to tell them our secret if they never told anyone, but they were waiting for me before actually taking them to our hiding spot and spilling it.

I was almost worried that Grant might be using his cool big kid status to bully these younger guys into it, but they were more than willing to come along and seemed eager to find out what all the hype is about. It was just shocking how quickly our wild plan was coming along, and we had Grant to thank for that. I wasn’t even that worried, if this went wrong it’d be his fault, not mine. I was just expecting we’d be telling our closer more trustworthy friends, not the first random kids from the neighbourhood they ran into that morning.

We quickly hurried James and Brent off to our hiding spot, making sure no one else saw us, and we told them the sanitized version first, that it was all just a secret circle jerk club where we can masturbate together without judgment. We all like getting ourselves off, right? So why not sneak away and do it together?

They almost didn’t believe us until we started pulling our dicks out one by one. I was going to wait until they agreed to pull their cocks out too, but Grant just went for it and Jay followed along, so I pulled my hard dick out too and proudly showed it off. Matt and Chris both seemed a little more shy and nervous this time, we were all still waiting to analyze how James and Brent would react. But pretty much taking charge of the situation again, Grant started telling them it’s okay if they just want to just watch first, he didn’t seem to care if they reciprocate or not, and just wanted to show off like some kind of exhibitionist. I mean it was definitely exciting to have 2 new virgins sets of eyes staring at my dick as I whipped it out and started stroking it right in front of them, but that wasn’t part of the deal!

Not willing to let Grant just dictate and have his way, I basically interrupted him and said no, if they want to watch then they have to pull their dicks out too. No free audience section, participate or leave. Maybe Grant was trying to groom them slower and gentler than I would have or something, because he just immediately changed his mind and agreed with me, whatever it takes to make them join in.

James and Brent were dumbfounded and obviously super nervous, I could see their hearts were pounding and I could almost hear the gears grinding in their heads. They had 2 options – run away looking like a bunch of pussies, or stay and be faggots with the cool older kids. Both of them hesitated for a few seconds, but one by one they made the right choice and pulled their shorts down. Their dicks were already hard, and it was so cool to see them grab hold of their shafts and start stroking right along with us after basically no convincing. This was wild how easy it was!

We asked them if either of them had ever done something like this before, assuring them we wouldn’t judge them no matter what crazy shit they might say, but they both said it was their first time. Not the first time jerking off, obviously, but definitely the first time in front of anyone openly. But now that we were up to 7 of us, it didn’t even feel that weird anymore, and I think they kind of got that vibe. This must be what all the cool kids and teenagers are up to all the time!

That kicked off the biggest circle jerk yet, and we quickly moved on to giving each other handjobs without even questioning that it’s the logical progression. Our new recruits were surprisingly into it even though neither of them had ever touched someone else’s dick yet, and it wasn’t like learning some new skill or anything. They fit right in, and they got pretty comfortable trading handjobs with us pretty quickly.

I don’t know if it was because they were totally new to it or what, but something stopped us from bringing up the topic of blowjobs. We didn’t want to scare them off by being too gay, and even Grant managed to contain himself and hold back for once. It was nice to see he had some restraint, we didn’t want to get ahead of ourselves.

We just kept the circle jerk going until we started making each other cum one after another, leaving James and Brent feeling great but still a little confused about the whole thing. Thankfully neither of them seemed to have any dilemma with post nut shame or regret either, they were just in shock that we’d ever let them in on such a crazy secret, and probably a little surprised by how fun it was. They had a lot to process as we all pulled our shorts back up and got ready to leave.

Ducking back out of our spot and heading back to the yard, as you do with such life-ruining secrets, we casually threatened to murder them if they ever told anyone, and to come find us anytime if they ever want to do it again. We went back to playing outside like normal boys for a while, hoping James or Brent wouldn’t change their minds and go snitch or something, but they ended up hanging out with us for most of the day, totally chill with what happened even after they had time to let it sink in. We hung out enough to get bored of whatever we were doing and start itching to go sneak off and do it again.

So we snuck off again, only this time we brought yet another friend Adam along. He had just moved into the apartment blocks and didn’t even go to our school, but he seemed like a nice guy, and if you were ever going to suspect an 11 year old boy of being a little bit femmy or gay, he was the one. Another perfect recruit, and we took him along with James and Brent, now 8 of us all together.

Adam was shy and hesitant at first, but he joined in on our quickly growing circle jerk almost too eagerly once he saw how nonjudgmental and oddly supportive everyone was. He also claimed he’d never done anything like this and it was his first time, and he was honest enough to say that he had thought about it and kind of always wanted to try something like this. I liked him right away, he seemed to be a lot more enthusiastic than James or Brent were, but somehow a little more submissive at the same time. He looked so innocent, and he had a beautiful little cock on him that started really small when he was soft at first, but grew pretty big and girthy when he got hard. It didn’t look massively long, but it was just thick and meaty and weighty, kind of like his stocky almost pudgy frame.

Still no mention of blowjobs in that circle jerk, seemed like a less likely confession to make as we suddenly had 3 more inexperienced members in our secret club. That would take a little more planning if we were going to bring that up, and we didn’t even dare say anything that day. But we did all make each other cum yet again, and by the end of the day we had grown our club beyond what any of us expected. But we could still do better, 8 was rookie numbers, gotta pump those numbers up!

That process repeated itself a few more times over the next couple days with a bunch of other neighbour boys, until we started having mixed results. I lost count but I must have jerked off with 10 or 12 different boys, basically most of my friends by the end of the week. The club didn’t stop growing until it suddenly didn’t go exactly as planned with another one of Grant’s friends, and we had to reassess the situation. We pretty much scared the last kid off trying to get him to jerk off with us, he just wasn’t into it. At least he still promised not to rat us out, and he seemed to hold to that word. We’d hit the limit, and in a mere few days it went from our little secret to almost everyone was doing it, basically a big open secret among all the neighbourhood boys.

We still hadn’t told any of the new circle jerkers that the original 5 of us were cocksuckers too, but that didn’t matter anyway, we still had our big slumber party coming up, and managed to make it all the way to that Saturday afternoon without anyone defecting and ratting us out. Our secret was still safe, and while it would have been even more fun to invite some of our new club members to sleep over too, it wasn’t quite time for that yet. Jay, Matt, Chris, Grant and I were the real core of the group that mattered, and the five of us were about to have more fun together than ever before.

🔞 Candy.AI 🔥 AI Sex Chat - Roleplay, Erotic Stories, Try for Free 🕹️

Please, Rate This Story:

(average: 3.40 out of 10 votes)