Who Did I Just Fuck Part 2

Amber and Ashley let me in on their planned set up and then let me in on more.

So I am standing in the kitchen with my cock out. Ashley who I thought was Amber is on her knees licking the cum from her lips with a smile and my wife Amber is standing in the doorway of the kitchen with her arms crossed and a smile. I am not sure what is going on. I am not in a good place.

“I.. I… I… but….but… you…. her…. she…. I… we…. OH FUCK!” I stammered. My wife and her sister who has stood up by now and walked over to the door with Amber. They are both smiling and giggling looking at me trembling as I try to process my actions and situation.

“Yes dear you were saying?” My wife replies. “Yes Craig you were saying?” Ashley says. I remember that I am standing there with my cock still hanging out and I quickly try to stuff it back into my shorts. They both burst into laughter and Amber finally says “Honey relax. You have been had by two pros. Come into the living room and I will explain everything.”

They walk into the living room and sit down together on the couch and I slowly follow and sit down in my chair. I’m just looking at them sitting there side by side and I for the life of me cannot tell which one is Amber and which one is Ashley. For the first time since knowing them I am totally confused.

Amber is the first one to speak. “Honey you are not in trouble. You did not make a mistake. You did exactly what you were supposed to do. You had no idea that we were setting you up with our plan to get you to fuck Ashley. We have been planning this for months now and we successfully pulled it off!”

I am just sitting there listening to my wife explaining to me that she planned on getting me to fuck her sister. Ashley pipes in “Craig I am sorry for tricking you into thinking that I was Amber. But we knew that you probably wouldn’t have ever seen me in the way that you would be willing to help me out. Please don’t be mad at Amber!”

I am finally able to speak without bumbling and I reply “I don’t understand what is going on here. Amber you know that I love you dearly and I never ever look at other women sexually including your sister Ashley. What in the world would possess you to set me up? Do you want a divorce or something? Are you trying to get evidence to use against me?”

She immediately gets up and straddling my legs sitting on my lap. She takes my face into her hands and looks me straight into the face and says “Baby I love you more than anything. I love you more than life itself. I don’t want a divorce. I am not trying to get you into trouble. You are a kind, generous, loving man who I know adores me and does everything that you can to make me happy and feel loved.” She then kisses me deeply and passionately.

When she finishes kissing me she sits up and continues “I also love my sister dearly. She has been through a lot in her life at no fault of her own. I have told her how amazing and kind and loving you are. How amazing you are in bed and how you always make sure that I am completely satisfied with our sex life.”

I am sure that I am blushing knowing that Ashley is sitting right next to us. “She hasn’t been with anyone since she got the divorce. She was afraid that she would get hurt again so she didn’t go out. She is a vibrant woman who happens to be a nymphomaniac just like me. She has needs that must be fulfilled and I knew that you were the perfect solution to her problem.”

Ashley stands up and walks over beside me and sits on the arm of the chair. “Craig I hope that you don’t hate me for this. But I haven’t had sex over a year and I was going crazy. Amber was gracious enough to allow me to use your cock for a bit. If you aren’t interested in me then I would understand and would never do it again and never speak of it. But we have talked about it and if you want you can fuck me like a whore anytime you want.”

I look at Amber and she is smiling and nodding in approval. “It’s true honey and it’s OK with me but the only stipulation is that there is no sneaking around. We all should know about whatever happens. We can even have a threesome if you want. If you want to fuck just her then you can.”

I am stunned by my wife’s and her sister’s proposal. But even though I don’t completely comprehend what they say my cock definitely understood everything. My wife definitely felt it as it hardened to full mast and was now poking her ass. She looks at Ashley and says “I’m not sure about his thoughts on it but his cock definitely likes the idea.

She slides back and Ashley is able to clearly see the tent in my shorts. “Mmmmmmm ummmmm I could definitely do with another round of that in my holes. I definitely didn’t get all of my itches scratched in the kitchen!” She responds with a hunger in her eyes as she licks her lips.

Amber looks down at me and says “How about it stud? Are you up for a little fun with your twin sluts?” My cock visibly jumps up and this doesn’t get by either of them. “We will take that as a yes!” They say in unison.

They both stand up and pull me up out of the chair. As they walk away towards the bedroom stripping off their clothes and giggling like two little girls. I follow them and strip out of my clothes as well. Ashley pipes up “Sister I hope you don’t mind if I get his cock in my holes first seeing as you get it all the time!”

“No problem sis just as long as you eat my pussy while you get fucked!” Amber replies. “OMG I haven’t tasted your pussy in a long time! You have no idea how glad you still enjoy me eating it!” I look bewildered again and Amber replies “We experimented in our younger years growing up.” With a wicked smile on her face.

Amber climbs up on the bed and lays down on her back with her head facing us. Ashley climbs up onto her sister in the 69 position. She props her ass up in the air and wiggles her ass at me and says “Please stick that hard cock back into my pussy before I go crazy!” She then proceeds to bury her face into Amber’s pussy. Amber is looking up at me and licks her lips and says “Come on baby I want to see your cock fucking my sister. I want to taste you both at the same time!”

I grab Ashley by the hips and push my cock into her soaking wet pussy as Amber starts licking my shaft and Ashley’s pussy. Ashley moans into Amber’s pussy as I proceed to pound her pussy. I can feel my balls bounce off the face of Amber as she slurps up Ashley’s juices and my cum from our previous session. After a few minutes of intense pounding Amber says “Fuck her ass now baby!”

Ashley lifts up her face just long enough to say “FUCK YEEESSSSSS PLEASE DO!” She quickly returns to eating Amber’s pussy. I pull my wet lubed cock from Ashley’s pussy and I slide balls deep into her tight asshole. Ashley groans like a wounded animal and Amber buries her face into Ashley’s pussy sucking any remaining cum from her.

I start driving my cock deeper into Ashley’s ass as my balls slap her pussy and my wife’s face. Ashley is grunting with every thrust and she is cumming over and over again from my cock and Amber’s mouth. Amber is cumming over and over from Ashley’s mouth. I am not close yet as I had just dumped a load into Ashley earlier. I reach around her chest and grab a double handful of her tits using them as grab handles as I destroy her asshole.

The sounds of slurping, bodies slapping together along with moans whimpers and gasps fill the room. Ashley tears her mouth away from Amber’s pussy and screams “FUUUUCCCCKKKKK MEEEEEEEE DADDY FUCK MY ASS!” Hearing her call me Daddy made my cock jump again and I double my efforts of fucking her ass senseless.

Amber screams out “YES DADDY PLEASE FUCK HER ASS LIKE A STUD!” Hearing my wife now calling me Daddy is all I can manage to take. I growl as I slam into Ashley’s ass one final time and pump stream after stream of my cum deep into her bowels. She screams out “OOOHHHHH MYYYYYYY GOOOOODDDDDDDDDD I CAN FEEL YOU CUMMING!”

She immediately cums again flooding Amber’s face with her juices. My wife is absolutely devouring everything she can and is even sucking my balls clean. As my cock begins to deflate I pull out of Ashley and I suddenly feel a mouth swallowing my cock. I look down and Amber is sucking the remaining cum from my balls and shaft.

I think to myself “WHAT A HELL OF A PLAN!”

🔞 Candy.AI 🔥 AI Sex Chat - Roleplay, Erotic Stories, Try for Free 🕹️

Please, Rate This Story:

(average: 4.92 out of 24 votes)