My Sister’s Sleepover – Chloe (Part 3)

11 year old Chloe has made me cum twice. Now her 13 year old friend caught us in the act.

“Come inside, you should join us. This is going to be so much fun.”

Chloe’s words were lost on me. I was terrified. I just… was caught. Fucking a kid. I’m FUCKED.

“Oh my god!” Ally whispered, putting her hand up to her face. I didn’t make a move, I just stood there terrified. My cock was still hard, but losing it’s edge since I had just climaxed a second time. Little naked Chloe stood right behind me, with some of my cum still covering her small belly.

Ally was a pretty girl, and much closer to my own age. While the age gap between me and Chloe was 5 years, it was only 3 with Ally, and I wouldn’t have been branded a pedo if I slept with her. Maybe a bit weird, but at least it wouldn’t ruin my life. I’d never really considered Ally as anything though. She always wore baggy clothes, and no makeup. She was cute, but most of her other friends were hotter.

Chloe stepped past me to grab Ally’s arm, pulling her closer into the room. “Come on, get in here!” Chloe said. Ally hesitated, and didn’t let Chloe guide her in. She stood at the doorway. “You two are having sex.” She said plainly. I couldn’t tell how she felt about it. Was it fear, jealously, confusion? It was stated so… strangely.

“No, I’m not ready yet. We’re just making each other cum. You should try it!” Chloe said excitedly. She tried again to grab Ally’s arm. I don’t know how to feel about Chloe’s enthusiasm. I’ve already came twice, and Ally was never on my radar before.

“Oh my god, keep your voice down, you’re gonna wake someone else up” Ally said, finally letting Chloe pull her inside. “I heard you making noises in here and thought you were getting raped or something.”

Well, a lot of people would say I was raping Chloe. Apparently she’s too young to consent, but obviously I didn’t fuck with that mentality. Technically I’m a minor too, so it’s not that bad. Right? Oh shit, I’m totally a pedophile. I just came all over an 11 year old girl, TWICE! And they were the best orgasms of my life. How can I jerk off now without thinking of this? How could I watch older girls in porn again? I don’t even know how to find kiddie porn, will it ever be possible to-

“He’s actually really sweet. He promised not to hurt me.” Chloe said, interrupting my train of thought. She closed the bedroom door again, then walked back in front of me. “Are you going to say anything?” She said, her little body inches away from mine. She looked up into my eyes, and I once again felt my cock twitch at the sight of her pretty innocent eyes. Was I really going to be able to go for a round 3?

“Uh, yeah…” I said, then cleared my throat. “Ally, I’m sorry we woke you up.”

“I’m just glad Chloe is okay…” Ally said, staring directly at my growing cock. “But I should go back to bed. I’ll leave you two to-”

“No!” Chloe said, a little too loudly. I grabbed her shoulders and Shushed her, nervous the next person through the door will not be so forgiving that I’m in a room with a naked 11 year old girl.

“Sorry.. ” Chloe said. “But Ally, I really want you to try touching his penis, it’s really a lot of fun.” She kept her voice down again, almost in a whisper.

Ally kept staring at me as she said “I’ve touched a lot of penises.” She sat down on my bed. “But, I uh… I’ll watch you try it out.” Ally blushed.

A spectator? That could be interesting… My cock was pretty sensitive at the moment, but I figured I could at least cum one more time. I turned so my now fully erect dick rubbed into Chloe’s back, signaling to her that I was ready to go. Chloe reached behind her and grabbed me, and without looking, started rubbing. She stared at Ally.

“Who’s penis did you touch?” Chloe asked her. She kept a steady motion on my cock, and I reached a hand out to balance myself on the wall.

“Just my boyfriends…” Ally said quietly. She didn’t look her in the eye when she said it. I noticed when she sat down her shirt tighten a little bit. I could tell she had some pretty large breasts for her age. I wonder if she’s telling the full truth….

“You don’t have a boyfriend” Chloe said, pressuring her.

“You said you touched multiple.” I said. I was kind of enjoying interrogating her about her sex life. I might not know otherwise.

Ally looked back at me, then down at Chloe, who briefly stopped stroking me to turn to the side. Once she was satisfied with her angle, she kept stroking, but she wasn’t looking at me anymore.

“Uh..” Ally said. “My brothers made me do it once.” She pulled her legs up to her chest, hiding what little of her curves showed through her shirt. Chloe turned away and focused on me again. “That’s not nice” she said, then stuck out her tongue. I felt her lick my cock up and down for awhile, the continue to stroke me. My cock ached from the prolonged sex, but the reality of it being done by a kid willed me to continue. How many times in life does a guy have this view? An 11 year old girl, gorgeous in every way, hazel eyes, messy short brown hair, completely naked… and sucking his cock? I can’t imagine many times…

Ally didn’t say much for awhile, and watched us. Chloe kept licking and jerking my cock, and I tried to enjoy the experience. Eventually, I asked if we could go back to the bed, and Chloe agreed. As I laid down, she got on top of me. Her sweet tight pussy was just inches away from my throbbing cock, and if I really wanted to… I could have forced her down on top of me. But I restrained, and allowed her to keep exploring my body. She rubbed her hands along my chest, and eventually my face.

I laughed as she stuck her small finger in my mouth, and it made her giggle too. Then I grabbed her head and pulled her toward me. I kissed her on the lips, and held her there. Her mouth was much smaller than mine, but it was heaven. She broke free and giggled. Her beautiful smile was contagious, and even Ally let out a giggle.

“What else can I do to make you cum?” Chloe said, rubbing my dick with her small hands again.

I wanted nothing more than to be inside her 11 year old pussy, but I knew she didn’t want that. Instead…

“Maybe a thigh-job?” I suggested.

“What’s that?” Chloe asked, scrunching up her face again as if I said something gross.

It was Ally that spoke up. “You use your legs to jerk him off.” She crawled towards us on the bed, and her face got very close to Chloe’s. “I’ll show you, just lie down on top of him.” Chloe giggled as she did what Ally said. “Okay.”

“Now fit his dick in between your legs, right underneath your vagina. Good.” Ally said. My cock felt incredible nestled in between her thighs. I could feel the heat of her child pussy on me, and I had to resist the urge to fuck her again. I tried to breathe. I did not want to be a rapist.

Ally started to coach Chloe on how to rub her thighs on my cock, and it actually felt amazing. I don’t know where Ally learned all this – probably from her brothers – but she was a great teacher. I guess Chloe and her were close too, because they were laughing like besties. I moaned as Chloe moved her small body along my cock, evoking a reaction in more laughs from both girls. They seemed so happy.

I suddenly leaned over to my side and steadied Chloe near me. I could see her small ass below me, and my cock down between her legs. I started thrusting faster. “Chloe, tighten your legs if you can. Your body is so hot.” She listened to me and the thigh-job finally started ramping up. Ally watched with eager eyes as I fucked her small friend. Chloe moaned as I grazed her pussy and grabbed the bedsheets. Her sounds turned me on even more.

I continued to fuck Chloe’s small child-thighs for a few minutes, but I couldn’t get close to cumming. This wasn’t working. I looked up to Ally as I fucked, and saw that she had actually taken off her pants. Her hand was in her bright pink underwear and she was masturbating as my cock thrusted. For a moment, she caught my eye and I smiled at her. She blushed and looked back down at my cock, but her hand came free of her underwear. She leaned up onto her knees and scooted over to the other side of the bed, and I could see her ass as she moved. It wasn’t bad. Chloe moaned again, but I was too busy staring at Ally to silence her.

I could see Ally had great legs. For a 13 year old she was really packing an ass too. I could never really tell before since she was always wearing such baggy clothes, but now with her bottom in front of me I saw it. She wasn’t as hot as Chloe, but she wasn’t bad at all. Maybe a 7.5 out of 10. And that was in the middle of the night, in baggy clothes, no makeup, and disheveled hair. I’m sure she could be really-

“AHH” Chloe moaned loudly as she came, her juices fell onto my cock as I slowed down. I put my hand over her mouth to muffle her sounds as she climaxed. Her entire body trembled and I held her close. Ally glanced nervously at the door. I guess she didn’t want to be caught in here anymore than I did.

“I love…” Chloe said, out of breathe. “doing that… woah… I want to do nothing… but cum… all the time..”

I ran my hands along her tiny chest and pinched her nipples. “I can arrange that, Chloe..” I teased. She giggled.

“That tickles!” She whispered, and squirmed her way from my grasp and off the bed.

My cock was still throbbing, so I stroked it slowly to alleviate the pain. Ally reached to her side to grab her pants, and laid them out. Apparently she had folded them. She stood up and started to put them back on…

“Wait.” I said. Ally paused and looked at me. “You know, you’ve seen me naked. And Chloe naked… it’s only fair we see you too.”

“Yeah!” Chloe said quickly. “He still needs to cum, and I think you should too! You can cum together!”

“I don’t know..” Ally said, but she dropped her pants onto the floor. Chloe walked up to her and reached to touch her chest. She grabbed her boobs through her shirt.

“Woah, you have really big boobs…” Chloe said. Ally smacked her hands away and crossed her arms. “Stop that! You.. you’re making this really hard.”

Chloe was trying, but not hard enough. I wanted to see this slut naked, and I was going to need to make sure of it personally. I sat up and scooted closer to Ally. I grabbed her hand and moved it slowly to my cock, and set it on top. As I did earlier with Chloe, I used Ally’s fingers to wrap around me. She didn’t resist.

“Your dick is so pretty.” She said. I laughed nervously at the compliment. Pretty? Not big, not nice… pretty… She kept touching it for a few moments longer before letting go.

“Ugg, just get naked already.” Chloe said impatiently, grabbing her shirt. Chloe tried to force it off, but she was too short. All she did was flash Ally’s tits to me, and FUCK were they large. You’d have thought they belonged to a fully legal pornstar. But the moment was gone quickly as her shirt fell back down. Ally didn’t say anything, but stared at us for a moment. She was thinking, and I hoped she made the choice to join us.

“Fine…” Ally said. “But give me a second.” Then she ran to the door, opened it, and left into the hallway.

“Uh, where’s she going?” I said, suddenly panicking. Was she going to tell someone? Am I screwed now? Is it finally over?

“Probably to the bathroom.” Chloe said. Ah, that makes sense…

Chloe sighed and laid back down on the bed, face first. I stared at her small ass and kept stroking. My cock was aching, and I really wanted to cum. I stroked to the thought of both these girls running their underage tongues along my cock as I waited on Ally.

Finally, Ally returned to the room and closed the door. She didn’t change her clothes, so I guess she just went to the bathroom as Chloe said. I looked at her, and kept stroking as I stared. Ally took a deep breathe and lifted off her shirt, revealing her porn star tits. Then she took off her panties, and threw them both into a pile with her pants from earlier. Now all three of us were naked.

Ally was way hotter than I originally thought. Where the hell was she hiding all this? She had a perfect hourglass figure and a tight waist. Her tits were massive for her age, and she had a nice ass on her too. “Woah..” I said, trying to compliment her. Ally blushed and skipped over to the bed to sit down.

“I’m still only going to watch.” She said.

Fuck. I guess I’m not getting to fuck that girl either. But at least I still had Chloe. I turned to her and saw she was laying down, her eyes closed. Was she asleep?

“Chloe?” I said, nudging her. Her ass bounced as I moved her, but she didn’t make a sound.

I guess we had been screwing around for awhile. I should let her rest. But now what the hell was I supposed to do? I’m rock hard and desperate to cum. I can’t just jerk off now… not after all of that.

I turned to Ally. “Chloe is asleep.” She blushed and shrugged. “I’d still like to see you cum.”

“Maybe you can help?” I said, desperate. But I guess it showed through because she shook her head. I stood up and considered my options. I could force Ally to help, but that didn’t seem right. I could wake Chloe up, but that seemed inconsiderate. I could jerk off.. but that wasn’t going to work… Or maybe…

I looked down at Chloe’s sleeping underage body. She might be fast asleep but I could still use her. I looked over at Ally as she watched me.

“Don’t tell her I’m going to do this.” I said, and gently lifted Chloe’s legs towards me.

“Are you going to fuck her?” Ally said, her voice rising. “She said she didn’t-”

“No, I’m just gonna try to…” my voice trailed off as I wrapped Chloe’s little feet around my cock. I used her feet to fuck myself, and actually started to enjoy it. I wasn’t usually into feet, but occasionally they can be nice. Especially on a child. Ally giggled.

“Her feet? You perv.”

“I need to cum.” I said plainly. Her soles were so soft, with almost no calluses. My cock thrusted in between them. In and out of her feet. They couldn’t have been more than a size 6? Maybe 5? She was so small. I stared down at her perfect round ass as I went.

“Why not just jerk off?”

“It’s not enough. I need one of you to finish me off.”

Ally paused… “Fine. Come here.”

“You mean it?” I said, slowing my pace with Chloe’s feet.

“Before I change my mind.” She said. I laid Chloe’s legs back down on the bed and made my way over to Ally. She reached out and grabbed my shaft, then got off the bed and onto her knees.

“I’ll show you what my brothers taught me..”

🔞 Candy.AI 🔥 AI Sex Chat - Roleplay, Erotic Stories, Try for Free 🕹️

Please, Rate This Story:

(average: 4.78 out of 40 votes)