Wrong hole? it's this or I cum in your fertile pussy and knock you up. You choose!

I'm 22 and this 17 year old girl I've been dating is a piece of work. I got a BJ and shot off in her mouth on our first date, fucked her the next day, three times. She is plain looking, decent body, but no waist, just straight down from chest to hips. She has skinny legs, hell, a skinny body, and a flat ass but even though she'd sucked about 12 cocks in her life, she'd only let two guys fuck her. That was one weekend, she was surprised by it and they both fucked her the whole weekend while out camping. So after getting two cocks about 12 times, plus she blew them both too, she'd not had a cock in her skinny, trimmed cunt in over a year. She let me fuck her on our second date. She was worried the whole time, her period had just ended so she was safe at least for a few days. I was dumping cum in that bitch for 4 or 5 days multiple times a day. Her cunt was fantastically tight. Everytime some of my cum would finally come out of that tight hole I made her wipe it up with two fingers and eat it. She seemed to love the taste of cum.

So after awhile, I took her temp, she was fertile and that corresponded to things a doc told me to help judge. I was fucking her then pulled out, and got behind her, We were on our sides, me spooning into her, and I stuck my cock up her tight hole again. Then pulling out, pinching the nipples on her little AA cup, barely there tits she was moaning and when I reached down to rub her little clit she went nuts. I put my cock at her asshole and watched as her movements on my hand pushed the head of my cock up her ass. I grabbed her hips and pushed all the way in. "AAAGGHH, no dont', you're in the wrong hole baby please take it out" I asked what she was talking about "You're in the wrong hole, please it hurts, it really hurts, take it out baby please" she was begging again. I was pumping that tight ass all I could, she kept repeating I was in the wrong hole. "No, I'm not, I'm in the hole that I want to fuck. You can't expect me to fuck only your mouth and pussy every damn time we're together. This is the right hole." I told her.

"No, it's not it's in my poop hole please you're hurting me". she was pleading again. "alright, I'll fuck your pussy more if you want. Just that if I do I'm gonna cum in it and you're fertile for the next few days. So it's either I buttfuck you and make you a 3 hole girl, OR I knock you up! You choose" I told her as I pulled out of her tight, rubbery asshole. "I'm cumming inside you somewhere so decide" I told her. Her head sort of slumped forward giving up in resignation to what was to com. "Put it back in my bottom" she whispered. "I don't understand you" I told her. "You need to tell me exactly what you want me to do to you. Do you want me to buttfuck you or I knock you up. And before you get to thinking all that romance shit. I'll still fuck you but I'm not marrying you, this will be your kid. Now what do you want me to do? buttfuck or knock you up?" I asked. "buttfuck" she answered. "What did you say? Tell me, what the hell you want me to do, and don't whisper it I can't hear that shit". "BUTTFUCK ME".

With that I stuck my cock back in that pretty little tiny pucker of an asshole she has. She was crying as I pumped even faster and harder. She was taking a really rough assfucking then I came. "At least you won't get pregnant from getting cum up your ass. It's tight too, really tight. Your pussy is nice and tight, but that ass, WOW it's great. I'll be fucking you there quite a bit." I told her. "You mean when I'm fertile in my front . . . my pussy?" she said. My answer "No, anytime I want it. "