Lily part 2 - fooling around with my ex's little sister

Hooking up for a second time with blonde HS teen Lily, my ex's skinny little sister

It had been a few years since I broke up with Lily's older sister, who was a thick big tittied sexy girl who was still younger than me. Lily was too young then but it's been a few years and she's grown up, almost out of HS.

I saw her on the street and gave her a ride home. She told me all about how she has been masturbating to the memory of me since she last saw me, when she used to listen to me fuck her sister.

She wasn't ready to lose her virginity so we made out, dry humped and eventually 69ed. She came so many times, a real little nympho. When I was leaving she still wanted to go again and I said, another time.

Then that time came. She texted me the next day, begging to meet up. I was busy all day and could only meet up late at night. It wasn't a problem since her mom was a mess and didn't pay attention to her anyway.

At midnight, she Ubered to my place. I hoped no one saw. Lily was a skinny blonde teen and looked even younger than she was from afar. Nude she had nice curves on her skinny body, her perky tits bigger than you would think. But clothed, she looked like a skinny little girl.

She showed up in a hoodie and quickly came inside my place.

She said, So this is where you live?

Yeah. This shitty apartment is all mine.

I love it, she said.

She walked close to me and started kissing me. We stood there making out. She was so much taller and thinner than her older sister. Lily's hair was frizzy and so bright blonde it was almost white. Her mouth was small but her lips were thick.

I squeezed her firm little ass and felt her body. Her pale white skin was so smooth and soft.

She leaned back and said, I don't think I'm ready for sex yet but... I'm ready for anything else. Your mouth made me cum so much. Even humping you made me cum so much. I can stay all night and leave in the morning if you let me. I want to feel your body and mouth all night.

We smoked weed and sat on the edge of the bed. She moaned loud last time so I put on some music.

I was less frantic than last time. We had all night and I wanted to calmly enjoy myself. Fucking her was off limits for the night but I knew I would be fucking her someday soon. She was obsessed with me.

She said, I remember how you used to have my sister not wear deodorant. That you liked her natural smell.

I said, It wasn't that I liked her stinky. I just hated the chemicals and stuff in the deodorant. If I'm going to bury my face in your armpit, I want it to be all you.

She smiled and said, I get it. Well, I didn't wear any. But even when I sweat, I smell good.

I said, I believe it. How did you know about the deodorant thing? Did your sister tell you?

She looked shy and said, No. I used to listen in on you two all the time. When you were fucking but also when you were just talking.

Damn, I wonder what all you know about me.

I know a lot. What you like. What you don't like. But it was a few years ago. Things might have changed.

I like you, I said and I lifter her arm up. I put my face in her armpit and breathed in.

You smell great.

Well I just showered. Soon, I'll be all worked up and sweaty. Idk how I'll smell then.

I said, Only one way to find out.

I took off her shirt then her bra. We made out while I slipped off her shorts and she was completely nude on my bed. Her pussy hair light in color and thickness. Her body tall and thin and perfect. Her tits a perfect perky B-cup with nice Half Dollar size nipples.

I got naked and we made out as she played with my cock with her hands and I felt her all over.

I said, I want to see you in every position. I sat up and leaned against the wall, stroking my cock as I watched her. She got in every position I said and her body looked amazing. On all fours, opening her asshole and cunt from behind for me, so tight and small. On her back, lifting her legs up and spreading wide. Putting her feet behind her head, stretching her thin body into a pretzel for me.

With her feet behind her head, her face giggling, her asshole and cunt popped up as high as her face, I couldn't help it any more. I leaned over and started eating her out. Her eyes flittered and she started moaning. I stuck my tongue up her tight asshole, pushing it open. She let her legs fall gown and settle on my shoulders and back. She came on my face. I knew this would be the first of many orgasms for her that night.

She said, I want to 69 again. Please.

I lay on my back and she sat on my face and put my cock in her mouth. She came over and over on my face as I licked her tight little wet cunt and tight asshole. Her pussy was soaked, drenching my face. I pumped a big load into her mouth and she kept on sucking. We went on and on 69ing, it felt so good, both of us high and so horny. Her body felt so great as I ran my hands over it all and squeezed everything while she sucked my dick and I licked and tongue fucked her holes.

After I came again I said I needed to piss. She followed me and watched me piss in the toilet. I looked over while I was pissing and she was standing naked, rubbing her little cunt.

She said, I used to listen to you piss after you fucked my sister. I can't believe I'm watching this. This is amazing. Can I... can I taste it?

I said, Only if I can taste yours.

She smiled.

I said, Better be quick. Gonna be done in a sec.

She quickly leaned over and my stream of piss was hitting her face and getting in her open mouth. She took a mouth full and let the rest of the piss pour out of her open mouth until I was done. She then closed her mouth and swallowed it all. She wiped her face and smiled.

I said, I can't believe you drank my piss but we haven't fucked yet.

She laughed and said, I think next time we might. I'm nervous about it.

Whenever you're ready, baby. You're mine now.

I saw her shiver with excitement when I said that.

I said, I like pissing all over you but I need to clean you off now. And I need your piss. Then I need to clean off. Let's take a shower.

Before I turned on the shower, I lay on the ground and had her stand over me. She pissed all over my body while she rubbed her cunt and I jerked my cock. She looked amazing with piss coming out of her little pussy, first running down her leg then getting stronger and shooting all over me. I was so hard. We showered and cleaned our piss off and she played with my hard cock the whole time.

I said, Let's go back to the bed and let me use your ass. I won't fuck your hole. Not until you are ready.

She said she trusted me.

I put lube between her plump little ass cheeks and rubbed my dick on her ass. She I felt her ass and rubbed into her, making her cheeks grip my ass as I moved back and forth. Her lubed up ass felt great. I wanted that asshole bad but I enjoyed the ass job, her little but thick ass cheeks on both sides of my cock, grinding into her. She was rubbing her cunt while I did it, laying on her belly on my bed. She came hard and kept rubbing.

She said, I want to fuck you. I do. I just don't want to get pregnant.

I said, I'm an expert at pulling out.

She said, I trust you, I just...

I said, You know what won't get pregnant. Your asshole.

She said, I know... But... Just the tip. When you are ready to cum. Just the tip. Fill my asshole with your cum.

That got me so excited. I kept grinding into her ass, getting more and more worked up, feeling all over her body, kissing her neck and face from behind. Her body shivering as she rubbed her cunt.

I pressed my hard cock into her lubed up asshole. She started to moan in a different way. I pressed the tip of my dick right into her little perfect asshole.

She wined, Just the tip.

The head of my dick is big and she was in pain as I pushed it in. Her little asshole was fighting me but I pushed it in. She screamed and covered her mouth. I let just the head of my dick stay in and I squeezed her ass and tits as I pumped a huge load up her asshole. I wanted to push it balls deep but I let just the head stay in her asshole.

Her little ass shook on my cock as my cum shot into her innocent pure shitpipe.

After I came I said, Are you okay?

Yeah. It hurts but all the cum in me feels crazy. It feels amazing. Pull it out.

I pulled my cock out and her asshole closed behind me, keeping all the cum locked in.

I said, Your asshole is so tight, it kept it all in. You'll be shitting my cum for a day or two.

She said, I don't know why that's so hot to me but it is.

She stood up and said, Wow, all the cum really is just staying in there.

I said, After a few months of me fucking your ass, it'll loosen some. Let's enjoy it while it is tight.

I was half joking but she liked it.

She said, You can loosen all my holes if you want. You can do whatever you want to me. I love that I can feel all your cum inside me. I'm going to get on the pill so you can cum in my pussy too. I want this all the time.

I took some pic and videos of her, in so many positions.

I lay on the bed with her on all fours, sucking my cock, tasting her asshole on my dick, and her ass and cunt popped up to the right of me. I filmed her as she sucked my dick and I played with her holes. She sucked my cock and I loosened her asshole with my finger and my cum started to leak out, running down her cunt and leg. I came again in her mouth.

The sun started to rise and we realized we had been going all night. We slept for hours. We woke up in the evening. We 69ed for a bit, I came twice, she came soooo many times.
She said, I think tomorrow I am going to lose my virginity.

I said, I've already been in your ass.

She said, Just the tip. Tomorrow, your whole cock is going inside me. Maybe not my ass but definitely in my cunt. I will be rubbing myself all night thinking about it.

Then she went home. She had school the next day but said I could pick her up after. During the day, while I worked, I would get texts from her about how she was rubbing her pussy through her pants at school during class, under the table. She sent me pics from the girl's bathroom. One her cunt with her pulling down her pants and pink panties and one of her open mouth.

She texted, So much of your cum just came out my ass in the toilet. Too much info?

I texted, No. I like knowing that, but no pics needed.

She sent a smiley face.

One text said, I didn't wear deodorant and I'm starting to stink. As long as you like it, I don't care if other people hate it. I'll be your stinky little girl.

Her last text said, Tonight is the night.

for part one
/2026/07/story-53146