The Big Setup - Chapter 6

Several days after the night in the hotel, Dolly calls Mike to come pick her up. Once in the car she explained her brother found out and wanted in on the fun.

Mike and Jimmie are 18. Dolly, Nicole, Jasmine are 15. Anita is 14.

I couldn’t stop thinking of the events in the hotel room that night, even days later. We talked every day usually, but I hadn't talked to her for a few days since I dropped her off the next morning. I made sure I kept my phone charged so when she called, I wouldn't miss it.

She called around five o’clock and asked me to come pick her up right away, she seemed upset. I told her I’d be right there as I walked out the door. Less than ten minutes later, I turned onto her street and saw her standing on the corner with a guy; he looked a little older than her.

He looked extremely happy, while she actually looked sad. As I stopped, she slowly got in the car as he waited on the sidewalk. As she spoke, I found out why she was upset.

Dolly told me he was her brother and that he found out about us by reading her diary. I was pissed that she wrote down what we did, I could get in so much trouble. What she told me next blew me away. She told me he wanted both me and him to fuck her at the same time. I was bothered, what choice did I have but to let him have his way, I didn’t want to in trouble, but this was her brother. How fucked up do you have to be to want to fuck your sister.

I sat thinking about what she just told me when she blurted out that he wanted to do it right at that moment or he was going to tell on us. I looked at her and asked if it was something she wanted to do. She stared straight ahead for a few seconds, then looked right in my eyes and told me she’d do it if it meant keeping me out of trouble. She told me she loved me, the first time she said it. When she said that, I wanted to kick his ass.

I sat there with rage building inside me when she put the window down and told him to get in the back. He hopped in excitedly and told me to drive to the nearest hotel. I pulled off and drove slowly, trying to think of a way to save Dolly from this asshole. It was a short time before Jimmy told us to pull into a really crappy looking motel. He told me to stop at room 118. I couldn’t believe him, he already had a room. He had balls, I had to give him that.

He jumped out of the car and opened Dolly’s door. He hurriedly pulled her out of the car and pushed her toward the hotel room door. I rushed around the car and grabbed him by the throat. He looked like he was ready to shit himself he was so scared. I quietly told him we were doing this because we didn’t have a choice, but I wouldn’t allow him to abuse or hurt her, no matter what happened to me. I let him go as Dolly started to cry. I walked over to her and gave her a hug. I glared at him as we walked into the room.

We slowly walked in the room to find Jimmy sitting on the bed in his boxers, with his dick forming a tent. He told us to get undressed. Dolly slowly moved to take her clothes off while she looked at me. I felt sorry for her. This is the first time since we met that she wasn’t pulling the strings. Adding to the fact that she was about to be forced to fuck her brother. When she took her bra off, my dick jumped to life as her beautiful firm tits bounced into view. When she took her panties off, I saw her pussy was still bare. The vision of her reminded me of my feelings for her that night of the foursome.

At that moment, I just wanted to hug and kiss her, but was interrupted from that thought when Jimmy told me to take off my boxers and he told Dolly to suck his dick. At the sight of Dolly climbing on the bed and leaning over to suck his dick, my dick became rock hard as I kicked my boxers off. I moved behind Dolly to eat her pussy so she could get some pleasure from all of this. No sooner than my tongue touched her pussy, he told her to stop. She sat up, looking confused. He said he wanted to find out if I sucked dick as good as her. I moved closer so I could punch him in the face. He stopped me mid stride by telling me he had an email scheduled to be sent at nine o’clock the next morning with proof I was fucking Dolly, which would throw our lives into chaos.

He told us if we refused to do anything, he would make sure the email was sent. Then he told me to suck his dick while Dolly sucked mine. I never did this before, and was repulsed by it, but Dolly looked ready to cry again, so I put my pride away and moved to the bed to take his dick into my mouth.

Dolly hungrily sucked my dick into her mouth and continuously deep throated my cock. It felt so good I almost forgot I was sucking Jimmy’s dick, only to be brought back by his moans and him thrusting to far making me gag a little. It wasn’t as bad as I thought, but it wasn’t something I would want to do again. Dolly had me cumming in no time and she swallowed every drop and kept sucking even as I softened. I was still half hard, even after just cumming.

I focused on getting him to cum, doing what I knew I liked. I couldn’t deep throat him, but I rolled his balls in my hand and stroked him as I tongued the hole on the tip of his dick. After a few more minutes, he announced he was going to cum. He us to get on our knees on the floor next to each other as he stood up and jerked his dick until he started to cum on both of our faces. The first shot landed on my face, then one on hers. When he was just about done cumming, he slid his dick into Dolly’s mouth and all the way down her throat, where he finished cumming. She swallowed obediently everything he gave her.

After he finished unloading in her mouth, he told us he had to go out, but he’d be back as he looked at us and started laughing and calling me a faggot for sucking his dick and letting him cum on my face. After he finished dressing, he told us we better be here when he got back. Soon after he left, Dolly moved to me and cleaned my face with a towel as we hugged while she said she was sorry. I told her not to worry, that we’d get him back. She looked happily at me and lay there while hugging me, then noticed my dick coming back to life with the closeness of her body.

She began to stroke me and massage my balls, while kissing me. She rolled me over and took my dick into her mouth, more passionate than before. After I was hard, she moved up and sank down on my throbbing dick. She moaned loudly as she roughly rode me. She was intent on getting me to cum. If she came too, it was a bonus, but she was going to make me cum to restore my manhood. Her beautiful tits bounced up and down. That made me forget all about her brother.

Her pussy was as tight as I remembered and had me cumming again in no time. Even after I came, and grew soft, she rocked back and forth, using my soft dick to help her cum. It didn't take her long to cum as she started rubbing her clit at the same time. She slowly rocked back and forth through her orgasm until she was to weak to continue. She collapsed on me as my dick slid out of her. We laid there for a little while before heading to the shower to get cleaned up. I had an idea and while Dolly was in the bathroom, I set my phone up behind the TV with the video camera recording focused on the bed by the door, set to motion activation. No one would ever see it.

Continued in Chapter 7