You’re on the naughty list

I convinced my sister she was on the naughty list, and had to let me play with her if she wanted to be put on the nice list.

Last year, on December 21st, I saw my 8 year old sister Ellie in her school Christmas play, she was dressed as a fairy, wearing a short tutu and leotard, it showed off her perky gorgeous ass beautifully, I was 13, and for some reason I was getting aroused by watching her dance around on stage in her outfit.

That night I couldn’t stop thinking about her and jerking myself off in bed filling my head with fantasies about her, I wanted to fuck Ellie so bad, I had to have her.

December 24th, Christmas Eve, our parents went out as usual, like they do every year, they go down to the pub and come back home in the early hours of the morning to put the presents out, so it was just me and Ellie that night.

I had a wicked idea, I found an old elf outfit in my dad’s closet and I put the outfit on and covered my face with a blue face mask, then when Ellie was in bed sleeping, at around about 10pm I sneaked in to her room, and I slid under her sheets next to her.

I managed to pull off her pyjama bottoms and rub her pussy over her panties for a few minutes before she woke up, as soon as she awoke I climbed on top of her and put my hand over her mouth, “Shush.” I sounded, then slowly removed my hand from her mouth.

“Who are you?” she asked.

“I’m an Elf.” I replied.

The she looked down at her bare legs, “Why are my bottoms off?” she asked.

“I need you to be a good girl and let me play with you.” I said.

“Why?” she asked.

Then I quickly made some shit up, “Santa say’s you’re on his naughty list…” I started to say, then she gasped and looked like she was about to cry.

“What? – Why? – What did I do?” she asked.

“I don’t know, but you must have been naughty. But it’s okay. Santa sent me, he said if you let me play with you, then he’ll put you on the nice list.” I replied.

She started nodding really fast, “Okay. Okay. I’ll play with you.” She said.

“You have to be a good girl and let me play. Don’t be scared at what I do. Just let me play, and you’ll be on the nice list.” I said, whilst pushing my fingers down the front of her panties and feeling her smooth warm pussy flesh beneath, my cock got very big and very hard, so I opened up my trousers and took it out.

“What’s that?” she asked, seeing my throbbing cock sticking out between my legs.

“That’s my candy cane. Want to taste it?” I asked.

She nodded, so I sat up and moved close to her head then held my cock in my hand and aimed it at her face, “Open.” I said, she opened her little mouth and I pushed it inside, sliding it over her tongue and between her soft cherry red lips, it was glorious.

I slowly face fucked her for a couple of minutes then pulled it out of her mouth, “Okay, that’s enough. Taste good?” I asked.

“Yep.” She replied, licking my pre-cum off her lips.

I moved back down the bed and quickly yanked her panties off, I briefly went down on her and licked her pussy, it was so warm, and tasted like pineapple, I could hear her lightly gasping and moaning, such sweet sounds.

Then I crawled up her body, wrapped my arms under and around her, then I pressed the tip of my cock against her soft spongy flaps, and thrust my hips forward as fast as I could, “Ungh!!!!” she moaned out loud, my cock went straight inside her, I felt her hymen rip open around my tip as it forced its way inside her.

My god, the tightness of her, wow, the inside of her pussy was so tight, not painful, but very tight, like perfect, her inner tunnel got very wet very quickly and I was soon sliding my cock in and out of her with ease, while still feeling the tightness surrounding my hard cock, “Oh, Ellie. Good girl.” I groaned.

I had been dying to do this for days, and I wasted no time, I fucked her fast and I fucked her hard, she put her hands on my waist and lifted her little legs up in the air, as I thrust repeatedly into her, “Ungh – Argh – Ugh – Oomf!” she moaned.

Her small bed was rocking, and the wooden headboard was banging loudly against the wall, the bolts and metal mattress springs were grinding and squeaking as I fucked her, it was a good job I wasn’t concerned about making any noise.

Then it happened, the greatest moment of my life, I came, ejaculating my load inside my kid sister’s pussy, my sperm shot out of me with speed, and it was a lot of sperm.

“You’re a good girl, Ellie. Santa’s going to hear what a good girl you’ve been tonight.” I said, pulling out of her and climbing off the bed.

She lifted her head up and looked down between her wide open legs, she saw my white sperm dripping out of her pussy and she picked up her panties to wipe it off, “Am I on the nice list now?” she asked.

“Definitely. I can guarantee that you are at the top of the nice list.” I replied, tucking my cock back in to my trousers, my cock felt numb, but totally amazing, “You need to go to sleep now. Oh, and you know the rule don’t you?” I asked.

“No?” she said.

“You can’t tell anyone that I was here. Or that we played together. It has to be a secret or Santa won’t be happy.” I said.

“Okay.” She replied.

“Right. Go to sleep. Merry Christmas, Ellie.” I said.

“Merry Christmas.” She said.

Then I left her room and went back to mine and got out of the outfit, I then laid on my bed smiling and laughing at myself, I couldn’t believe it, I had just fucked my kid sister, and she was great.

I want to fuck her again this year, but need to come up with another plan, I can’t use the elf and naughty list again, but I can’t wait to fuck her again, I wonder if her pussy is still tight after a year, oh, and she’s started to grow boobs this year, I’d like to suck on those.

Maybe I can make this an annual tradition, just me, fucking my little sisters pussy every Christmas.

🔞 Candy.AI 🔥 AI Sex Chat - Roleplay, Erotic Stories, Try for Free 🕹️

Please, Rate This Story:

(average: 4.76 out of 66 votes)