# # #

Sophie’s Choice – Part 5

4535 words | 11 |4.78
By

I hope everyone likes this story, Sophie and I are found out by her mother, but all’s well that ends well.

After laying there for a good 10 minutes thinking about the dream I just had, stroking my still hard cock. I put my pants on and tip-toed through the bathroom and into the hallway. The house was dark except a few dim nite lights scattered throughout. I slowly opened Sophie’s door, took a look behind me and went in. The door knob made a loud click when I shut it. I froze for a moment before removing my jeans and sneaking across the floor to her bed. I gently slid under the blankets trying not to move the bed. I inched my way to her warm body. She was wearing a long silky nightie. I reached around her and cupped one of her boobs and lightly squeezed it. Then I flicked my thumb back and forth on her nipple. She moaned quietly and turned on her back. I teased the other nipple making it hard. Her hand pulled my face to hers. We locked lips in a deep passionate kiss.

She whispered in my ear that her room was directly over her parents and that we can’t do anything. She wanted us to sneak back to my room. My hand moved down over her tummy and to her pussy. She tensed up and stopped me. I whispered ok, I’ll go back to my room. I once again put my pants on, and eased my way back to my bed and waited.

It wasn’t long before my door opened, my heart pounded with anticipation. Sophie crept across the floor shedding her night gown along the way then crawled under the blankets with me. She snuggled up to me and whispered “hi”. Her satin smooth butt pressed against my dick, she had her back to me, I run my hand up her thigh and over her ass then moved to her tummy finally stopping at her breasts. Her butt wiggled slowly, I wedged my boner between her butt cheeks and I slowly slid it back and forth enjoying the feeling of it, I tried to got it to her pussy but she held her legs together. I whispered to her to let me in.

She bent one leg allowing me to reach the entrance of her moist hole then lowered her leg again trapping me. I pushed with a few thrusts and was just inside of the lips. She rocked her hip enough for me to penetrate her. With a loud sigh, she pushed back against me taking most of it inside. I used long and slow strokes, she moaned so sweet as I pushed all the way in. We stayed in this position for a while, “oooh, I missed this so much”, she said and lifted her leg again. I really wanted to taste her juices now.

I pulled out and moved to the foot of the bed. Her feet were ice cold so I rubbed them to warm them up. I even put one of her pretty feet in my mouth and licked her tiny toes. She flinched telling me that she was to ticklish for that. I kissed and licked my way up one leg and down the other, when I made my way back up to her cunt, she took a deep breath and raised her ass off of the bed to meet my mouth. I sucked on her clit like it was a nipple, she covered her mouth with her hand to keep from screaming. The little patch of hair tickled my nose as I ate her out, it was so soft and fluffy. The more I stuck my tongue in her, the more I thought that she must have the best tasting pussy in the world. Her hips were rocking around until she started have an orgasm, then they thrust up hard against my mouth, her orgasms lasted only about a minute and I loved to watch her face. Seeing how much she loves it just makes me want to lick her more, but I was ready to fuck this sexy girl.

I sat up on my knees just looking at her, she was incredibly beautiful, I think her tits had gotten a little bigger in the 2 weeks we were apart. When the orgasm was over and she opened her eyes and saw me looking at her, she just grinned and asked, what’s next? I took her cold feet and placed them on my chest, she scrunched up her toes and tugged on my chest hair. I slapped hey pussy with my dick and told her to be nice, then I swirled the head around her mound and started inside. I plunged deeper and deeper as we started fucking. Her little tits were jiggling to the rhythm of my thrusts, I really wanted to pound on it hard but I was afraid it make too much noise so I took my time, making each stroke count. It didn’t take long fucking that tight pussy to make me cum, I wanted to just bury my dick in her as deep as I could and shoot my cum inside of her. But when I was ready to cum, I grabber feet and squeezed them together around my shaft. I fucked those perfect tootsies for a moment until my white hot cum shot out covering her pussy and the fuzz above her mound. She grabbed my dick  and stroked the last few drops.

I kissed the bottom of both feet and laid down beside her. I used the black panties to wipe the cum off and dropped them to the floor. She snuggled up next to me, I put my arm around her and hugged her tight. She hugged me even tighter and said that she wanted us to be together always and forever. I wanted that too, but how?

She snuck back to her room some time after I fell asleep. The next thing I knew someone was knocking on my door. “Are you up yet, sleepy head”, Jessica yelled through the door, “breakfast is ready”. I told her that I would be down soon. So I dressed and headed downstairs. Sophie came out of her room as I passed her door, she was still wearing her night gown. She pulled me into her room and wanted a good morning kiss. I gave her a big bear hug, lifted her off of the floor and kissed her. Let’s go, everyone else was in the kitchen filling their plates, all still wearing their nighties to my surprise, including Jessica. The robe she had on didn’t leave much to the imagination, it was thin and almost see through. I couldn’t help but to think about the wet dream I had about her. Her tits sagged a little farther south than I thought, but her nipples still pointed forward and they were still beautiful. I watched them bounce and jiggle as she moved around the room. Sophie caught me staring at her mom and gave me a dirty look. I just smiled and winked at her.

After breakfast, the kids wanted to go sledding, so Jessica took the little ones to get dressed. Sophie scampered upstairs to change. The rest of us cleaned the mess in the kitchen. Michael reached into the top cabinet and retrieved a bottle of Jack Daniels and sat it in front of me. “Care for a snort before braving the cold”, he asked? “You bet” I answered as I slid my coffee cup closer to the bottle. He poured a little in then stopped and looked at me, I nodded my head to tell him more. We sipped our whiskey while everyone got ready. We were just talking about work stuff when I noticed Jessica going upstairs. I panicked, “Those cum covered panties are on the floor beside my bed”, screamed in my head. “Excuse me for a minute”, I said to Michael then walked quickly up the stairs. I caught up to Jessica just as she was going in my room. She said she was going to change the sheets on the bed, “I’ll help you” I said and walked quickly past her to the far side of the bed. They weren’t there, now I’m really freaking out. Where could they have gone?

I wanted to find them before she did. There might have been cum stains on the sheets too. I started stripping the bed as she got fresh sheets. She told me that she didn’t need my help, but I insisted. Thank goodness the sheets were clean, and the undies fell to the floor while she wasn’t looking. I snagged them up and shoved them in my pocket just as she turned toward me. She looked right at me and asked if I was ok. “Yeah, I’m good” I said, “I think I drank too much Jack”. I walked to the restroom and shut the door. I was sweating bullets and could barely breathe, I splashed some cold water on my face and tried to calm down. “Crisis averted” I thought to myself. Jessica tapped on the door and asked if I was ok. “Yes ma’am, I’ll be out in a minute” I said.

The rest of the day was filled with wintery fun, sledding, snow angles and snowball fights. Sophie was being a brat to me though, jealous of me eyeballing her mother. Her and I walked to the top of the hill together, I appologized and tried to explain that was a normal thing for a man to do. I also told her that I was in love with her. Tears of joy welled up in her eyes, “I love you too” she said. We went a little farther over the hill, out of everyone’s sight. She jump on me with her legs around me, we kissed for a long time while I squeezed her ass with both hands. I slapped her butt and told her that was enough for now. She jumped down and got on the sled, “push me” she demanded. I gave her a good shove and down the hill she went, I hopped on mine and followed her down.

The day went by really fast, it was time for me to go home. I said my goodbyes and was walking out to my car, I looked up and saw Sophie standing in her bedroom window wearing that fur coat, as I waved, she opened the coat. She was totally naked again, she pressed her tits against the glass and waved goodbye.  On the way home, my head was spinning from all if the questions I had bouncing around in my brain. What had I done to this child? Where do we go from here? By the time she’s old enough to date or get married, I’ll be in my 30s. Will she still want me then? What do we do in the meantime?

Around 10 o’clock that night my phone rang, it was Sophie calling. I answered, “hey baby”, she giggled and said hi. She said she just wanted to hear my voice before going to bed. I told her ok, but it’s really not a good idea for her to be calling me. We talked for a while, she asked some of the same questions that I had. I didn’t have the answers yet. I assured her that I did love her and wanted to be with her.

“I wish I were with you now” she said, “I’m horny”. I chuckled and asked her what she was wearing, “my night gown, no undies”. I told her that I wasn’t wearing anything, just about to shower.
She sent me a mirror selfie, she was holding the front of her gown in her teeth, showing her luscious boobs and pussy. “Mmmm” is all I said, it was enough to make my dick jump to attention. I stroked myself as we talked, she was telling me that she was fingering her pussy, “it’s so wet” she said. Her breathing was short and quick as she rubbed herself, she was getting close to cumming. It made me jack my dick faster. She was making her usual little moaning sounds, “I’m cumming, I’m cumming” she said in a raspy whisper, I hurried my pace, I wanted to cum too. She dropped her phone as she had her orgasm, I stroke my dick a bit more then I told her that I was cumming too.  I could hear her voice shaking, “my pussy feels so good”, “I love you”.
“I love you too sweetie”, I told her. We said goodnight and hung up.

We didn’t have any opportunities to get together over the next 2 months except through emails and phone calls.  We saw each other at the store regularly but had very little contact. Sophie video called me one night, her phone was propped up on a towel, she was taking a shower and let me watch her. She talked to me the entire time while she washed her hair and lathered up her slender body. Her tits were almost the size of softballs now, very firm and perky. I was masturbating the whole time she showered, she put on quite a show for me. She rubbed her clit frantically try cum, she gave me a super close up of pussy while she had an orgasm. My dick was about to explode so I held my phone below it as the cum sported out, some of it landing on the screen and camera. She licked her phone pretending to eat my milky sperm.

Puberty was in full bloom now, with it, those pretty pink nipples stayed puffy most of the time. They are so tender and lovely. There is more silky soft fur that covers her entire mound. The little girl I use to know is now a vibrant young lady that loves to be intimate.

I wiped my phone clean and continued to watch her dry off and get dressed for bed. She put on one of her sisters little short pink nighties with black lace around the bottom and pink panties.
That was a risky because I heard her sister asked who she was talking to. “Nobody”, she replied. She whispered “I love you, goodnight” and ended the call.

I don’t think she knows just how sexy she is, damn I wish we could be together more. I longed to have a few hours alone with her that gorgeous young body.

The weather finally started getting warmer and with it, Sophie was allowed to ride her bike around town again. About once a week she would ride to my apartment, often showing up pretty early. We would spend the best part of the day laying 5thin bed talking, laughing, watching TV and making love. This went on for the entire summer. After school started back in the fall we didn’t see much of each other. She made the volleyball team and that took up most of her afternoons. She was also a member of the debate team which meant extra homework and studies.

When we did get together, her favorite thing was to sit on my face while worshipping and sucking on my dick. I started to finger her asshole while eating her pussy. She didn’t like it much at first, but eventually let my lick it and stick my tongue and finger in it.
She began to have multiple orgasms while I munch away on her crotch, her delicious juices would be all over my face. Sophie still had trouble getting my entire cock in her mouth without gagging herself, but she had become an expert at making me cum hard.

A few days before her 13th birthday, she showed up on a new Moped that her dad bought her. She was ecstatic that only takes 15 minutes to get here. She said she was going to get her licence so she could legally ride it anywhere. It was great to see her in such a good mood. She had matured quite a lot over the past year. Not only her body, but her mind too. Sophie had grew about 2 inches taller in the past year, and her boobs were filling out a C-cup bra. I couldn’t believe that she was still interested in me. She decided that she wanted to be a lawyer someday. Her and her dad had her future all planned out as far as required classes and grades, possibly getting a scholarship to get into the best colleges. I didn’t ask about our future, but it was becoming clear that I  wasn’t going to be with her much longer. There’s no way I’m going to get in her way of having the life she wants, the life she deserves.

I’ve wanted to stop seeing her, I know it’s wrong for us to be together, but damn she is the best piece of ass I’ve ever had. I love the way she acts like a typical 13 year old around other people, at home or at the store, then becomes a tiger in the bed when we’re alone. It all seems so normal for her.

Ok, fast forward 3 years. Our times together had been very limited, but we were still very much in love. Only getting to hook up 2 or 3 times a month.

One Friday Michael asked me to come for dinner that evening. He said we had a lot of “business” to discuss. I arrived at their house a little early, Jessica was busy in the kitchen, we chatted as she rinsed the veggies. Santa had brought her a boob job the previous year since she was no longer breast feeding. I watched them moving under her loose blouse as she chopped the food, they were still about the same size but were not sagging any more. She had also been hitting the gym to tone up her legs and ass. She looked amazing, a super MILF. Sophie came bouncing down the stairs, she had on a sports bra and yoga pants, her legs and ass had thinned a bit, she had also been working out with her mom, “Hi Cal, I’m glad you made it”, she said. She puckered her lips for me to kiss her, I hesitated because Jessica was watching us. Sophie’s voice was ecstatic as she told me that her mom had known about us for a while. I looked straight at Jessica, she just winked at me and said, “it’s cool”. I gave her a quick kiss on the lips, I was awfully nervous now. “How about your dad”, I asked? She answered, “we’re going to talk to him tonight”. “OH SHIT”, I thought.

Well, after a delicious dinner, the youngsters went off to play video games. Jessica opened a bottle of Moscato, and poured each of us a glass. She was standing behind my chair with her hands in my shoulders when she said that Michael had something to say. Sophie and I were holding hands under the table, not knowing what was about to happen.

Michael started off saying what a wonderful employee I was, and after 8 years of grinding away that he was making me the new General Manager of their store. “Congratulations”, he said as he raised his glass. It was a great surprise to me because Michael had been the only manager of the store, but I was excited and said, “thank you sir”.

“Now”, he continued, looking me straight in the eye, “I understand that you and Sophie are something of a couple”. Jessica patted my shoulder for reassurance as Sophie squeezed tighter on my hand. “Yes sir, I love your daughter with all my heart, and with your permission I wish to marry her someday”, I said without hesitation. He nodded his head and then asked Sophie what she wanted. She told him that she also loved me and wanted me to live with them. Her oldest sister had gotten married and moved out last year and the other was away at college. He swirled the wine around in his glass then gulped it down.
He looked at Jessica, who was smiling from ear to ear, then said, “what do you think about Cal moving in with us so he and Sophie can be together and won’t have to sneak around anymore”. “I think it’s a wonderful idea”, she hugged my neck and kissed my cheek saying, “welcome to the family, Cal”. Michael went to the cabinet and retrieved a bottle of old brandy and 2 glasses, “if you ladies will clean up, we’re going to the study to hammer out the details of our new arrangements”, he said with a smile. After about an hour or so of drinking and discussing, Michael was pretty drunk, he told me that he knew something was up with Sophie for a month or so, since he found out that  Jessica took her to the doctor for birth control pills, but didn’t know it was me until yesterday. I’m glad he didn’t know that we’d been fucking for 4 years, he might have killed me. He also told me that he was 21 when he met Jessica, she was only 15. He made me promise to wait until she graduated high school before we got married.

Afterward, he retired to their bedroom,
I was still in a state if shock, first I get promoted, which comes with a fat salary, then I’m invited to live with the love of my life.

I ended up spending the night there, Jessica told us that she would turn up the volume on their TV. Once she went to bed, Sophie and I headed upstairs and went to her sister’s old bedroom on the far end of the house. She told me to wait there as she disappeared into the hallway. I undressed as I waited, my dick was already rock hard with anticipation. I was sitting on the edge of the bed when she came back, her hair was in a bun on top of her head. She was wearing a neon green teddy with black lace around the bottom, the sheer material did little to hide those puffy pink nipples as she did a pirouette in the middle of the room. “You look gorgeous”, I said. She removed the matching panties and slung them to me, “put those on” she demanded, I did as she asked. Her eyes were glued on me as I wiggled into them, my throbbing dick was sticking out if the top of them a good 3 inches. She giggled the ran and jumped on me, we fell across the bed locked in each other’s arm, her kisses were hard and passionate. She climbed on my chest and sat pinning my arms to the bed with her knees, that sopping wet pussy was just out of reach of my tongue, she had shaved her cunt bald, her hot juices glmed her fingers worked feverishly on her clit as she teased my wanting mouth. She was watching me watching her tits jiggling about, she was about to have a huge orgasm, then she slid up enough to smother my face, her hands grabbed each side of my head then held me there as her juices flowed into my mouth until I could no longer breathe. I had to slap her ass to make her stop. “Damn, that was intense”, she said, as her body continued to have a few more quivers. I struggled to get my arms free then I managed to roll us over, her legs were still around my neck, I buried my face hard into her pussy, I used my nose to rub the clit as my tongue plunged deep inside of her. She was about to cum again, but I didn’t let up, her legs were sticking straight up and her beautiful feet were shaking wildly as an explosion of orgasms rocked through her body. She finally pushed my face away saying she couldn’t take any more. I raised up on my knees, pulled the panties to the side, my super hard cock was just touching her wet mound. I spread her pussy lips apart with my left hand and slapped that clit with my dick over and over, making her jump and squeal every time.
I penetrated the opening and bottomed out, I rubbed my pelvic bone against her mound. She was thrashing around like never before, I thought she was going to tear the sheets as she grabbed them.

I started really pounding that sweet cunt with everything I had, her hips raised off of the bed meeting my thrusts with her own. I was about to cum harder than I ever had, I pulled out just as I shot a stream of cum that almost reached her chin, I rammed my dick back inside and fucked her with long, slow thrusts until I was going to cum again. This time when I pulled out, she slid down in the bed and swallowed my entire shaft sucking my balls dry. I laid down beside her, both of us sweating and out of breath. She removed the cum soaked teddy and pressed her tits against my side. I held her in my arms as we talked about how happy we were and about our future for most of the night.

The next morning there was a light tap on the bedroom door, Sophie grabbed a blanket and went to see who it was. It was Jessica, she had brought us orange juice with toast and orange marmalade.
She came in with a huge smile on her face, she was truly happy to have me there with her daughter. She placed the tray on the dresser and sat on the edge if the bed. “I hope you guys had fun last night”, she said, “I tried not to listen, but my curiosity got the best of me”. She had walked to the top of the stairs and could hear Sophie screaming with pleasure. Then she surprised us by saying that she got super horny and fingered herself to climax while listening at the door. “Mother!”, Sophie shouted, I was quite embarrassed by it because the chubby I had just went to full mast. “I’m glad that my daughter has found someone to satisfy her so completely”, she said while looking straight at my boner under the sheet. Before she left the room, Jessica handed me a company credit card and told me that they were giving me the day off to go shopping for new clothes befitting their new GM. “Take Sophie with you, she has excellent fashion sense.

After Jessica left the room, Sophie pulled back the sheet and saw my dick standing at attention. “So, my mom makes you horny”? I tried to play it off as just morning wood, I got up to use the restroom. I never told her about the dream I had about her mom. Sophie waited for me to piss then came in, she pressed her tits on my back. She reached around and squeezed my still semi hard cock. She said, “I’m going to shower, want to join me”? I answered, “Of course I do”.

THE END

🔞 Candy.AI 🔥 AI Sex Chat - Roleplay, Erotic Stories, Try for Free 🕹️

Please, Rate This Story:
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
(average: 4.78 out of 32 votes)

By # # #

11 Comments

  • Reply Anon daddy ID:1dkt04835laa

    Nice. I loved all 5 parts

  • Reply Cal420 ID:1idz47cet0d

    Just published a continuation of this story, it’s called Lucky Man. I hope y’all like it

  • Reply Guy ID:zcx45nxucon

    Best story ever

    • Cal420 ID:1idz47cet0d

      Thank you

  • Reply Cal420 ID:1idz47cet0d

    Thanks Kalee, I’ll hit u up later.

  • Reply Cal420 ID:1idz47cet0d

    Thanks everyone. I really appreciate the good vibes. I’m planning to write more in the near future, and yes Jessica will be involved

  • Reply Depressed Korean ID:1ei42s69fpe4

    Maybe, I can be your new stepbrother 😉

    • Cal420 ID:1idz47cet0d

      LMAO

  • Reply Mr wolf ID:10o3ln2y49i

    Fucking amazing story. Well written and enjoyed every chapter. Sad to see it end. Would love to know how it goes with him moving in, and possibly Sophie allowing Jessica to join in.

    • Bigpapa3300 ID:1eq7u6n3fqfw

      Yeah same here

    • Cal420 ID:1idz47cet0d

      Thank you Mr wolf. It only gets better from here